Salt bread has a smart bit of pastry logic packed into a small roll: a soft, milk bread–like center and a crisp, buttery crust. The style, called shio pan in Japan and sogeum-ppang in Korea, sits somewhere between a Parker House roll, Asian milk bread and a croissant. [Hana Asbrink’s salt bread recipe](https://www.bonappetit.com/recipe/salt-bread-shio-pan) is the subject of this month’s BA Bake Club episode, where Asbrink joins hosts Jesse Szewczyk and Shilpa Uskokovic to explain how the rolls get their texture. The episode has a goodbye tucked into the baking lesson. Uskokovic is leaving Bon Appétit after five years to pursue other projects, and says she’s proud of the community she helped build with Szewczyk. Bake Club began as an idea in 2023; it now has more than 10,000 Substack subscribers. Uskokovic plans to keep baking along with listeners from the other side of the show, while Szewczyk will continue hosting. You can [follow Shilpa on Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/shilpauskokovic/?hl=en) for news of what she does next. ### The technique behind the crisp crust Asbrink says salt bread originated in Japan around the mid-2010s, then gained popularity in Korea. Versions vary, but her recipe pairs a crustier outside with the tender interior associated with milk bread. The key is shaping salted butter into the dough: as the rolls bake, some butter escapes and fries the bottoms and edges. A final brush of melted butter adds another layer of richness. The dough starts with tangzhong, a cooked mixture of flour and water that thickens into a gel. It helps the bread hold moisture, giving the crumb its soft, fluffy texture. Bread flour supplies the structure and chew; mixing matters too. Asbrink recommends kneading for 20 to 25 minutes, ideally with a mixer, until the dough stretches thin enough to pass the windowpane test without tearing. It’s possible to knead by hand, but that’s a serious workout. After the first rise, the dough is portioned into roughly 70-gram pieces. A kitchen scale helps keep the rolls close in size, which makes their bake more even. Skip the extra flour on the counter: the dough already has enough fat, and added flour can make the finished bread tougher. Shape each piece into a ball, then a tapered cone, roll it thin, tuck in frozen butter, and roll it up like a small crescent. After a second rise, the rolls get a light spray of water and flaky salt before baking. The dough can rise slowly in the refrigerator, so the recipe can fit around a busy day—or be made in one. Bake Club invites readers to send questions through [Substack](https://babakeclub.substack.com/) or by voice memo or email at [email protected].

Why salt bread gets its signature bottom

The defining trick in salt bread is hidden inside the roll. Hana says each piece of dough wraps around a frozen tablespoon of salted butter; the dough itself already contains unsalted butter. After another rest, the tops get a spritz of water and a pinch of flaky salt. Then the rolls go straight onto an unlined, hot sheet pan on the oven’s bottom rack. That last choice is deliberate. As the butter melts, it escapes through the dough and fries the underside against the pan, leaving a dark, crisp base. The rolls may look wrong while they bake. Hana’s advice is to wait for them to turn golden, then brush the hot buns with the melted butter left on the pan. The porous tops soak it up, and the pan should be relatively dry by the end. Jesse notes that the butter will have browned. The result is a sharp contrast: a soft roll above, a bottom as crisp as a potato chip. Shilpa says that combination made Hana’s version stand out. She’d tried another salt bread at an Italian fusion restaurant, while Jesse had also tasted one elsewhere; neither found those as successful. Shilpa praised the size and texture of Hana’s rolls, though she found the other version greasy. It was served warm, with egg salad as an option. Hana’s rolls are rich enough to eat on their own. For a more hands-on approach, she suggests unfolding one to reveal its shape, or scrunching it first to appreciate the crust before tearing it open. Inside, there’s a hollow where the salted butter sat.

Shaping takes patience

Listener questions turn to the recipe’s cone-shaped dough step. Nico wondered why the dough goes from balls to cones and then to triangles, especially after their cones drooped during the rest and needed reshaping. The finished rolls were plump and spiraled, if not especially tight. Hana says the pauses between shaping steps give the dough time to relax. Skip the cone stage and move straight from balls to triangles, and the dough may spring back—much like pizza dough that keeps shrinking as you stretch it. The recipe allows 30 minutes between stages. A one-minute Instagram reel demonstrates the shaping, including the cone step. Nico’s drooping cones may have been over-proofed, Hana and Jesse suggest. Dough that has risen too far can become slack and harder to shape. They can’t diagnose it from the description alone, but the baked rolls were smooth, risen and nicely browned, so the process ultimately worked. Maria’s rolls raised a similar question. She said the dough kept springing back; her finished spirals were much flatter than Nico’s. Hana and Jesse thought over-proofing might explain the shape. Jesse adds that dough can seem puffy yet collapse during baking if it has risen too much. The two still looked good and tasted great, Maria reported.

When the bottoms burn

Amy’s rolls browned so heavily underneath that she pulled them from the oven early. She wondered whether her dark pan was responsible. Her first batch, made and baked the same day, was difficult to shape but rose well. On a second attempt, after a two-day cold proof, the dough was so sticky she had to flour it heavily to roll it. She planned to try again. Hana says dark pans generally retain more heat, which can make the bottoms brown faster; she and Jesse recommend aluminum sheet pans. A dark pan can behave like cast iron compared with stainless steel, Jesse explains: it holds heat more intensely. Hana adds that the dark pans she has used also tend to be thinner, so they heat and spread heat more quickly. Amy baked on the lowest rack, which the recipe recommends because it’s often the hottest part of an oven. But ovens vary, and Hana thinks Amy’s may run hot enough that the middle rack would work better. Jesse agrees that rack position has an unusually visible effect on these rolls. Emily reported a similar problem: her salt bread burned underneath in about 10 minutes, even though her oven is usually consistent. She moved the rolls to the middle rack and plans to try again after the frustration fades. Hana suggests using the middle rack next time and says the recipe’s headnote may need to acknowledge how much ovens differ. Gas and electric ovens can each have their own hot and cool spots, so the first bake may be the best guide to adjusting the next one.

The trick with salt bread’s dark bottoms is knowing when “well browned” has crossed into burnt. That judgment is mostly sensory: if the smell shifts from caramelized to something closer to burnt toast, check a roll’s underside. At the recipe’s oven rotation, inspect one bun and, if it’s already getting too dark, move the tray to the middle rack. If your oven runs hot, check after about three minutes instead of waiting the full five to eight. Lowering the heat or letting the rolls sit off the heat briefly can also help. The first ten minutes are meant to be hands off; after that, your eyes and nose can tell you when to adjust. The Baker of the Month is Kaylee, whose photos show three puffed salt bread rolls alongside a Jellycat croissant plush. She also shared the cone shaped dough and an improvised rolling setup: a heavy, uniform object and a bottle of wine. The result, from the visible portion, looks evenly rolled. That’s a good picture of the Bake Club spirit: work with what you have, and enjoy the wine after the bake. The closing game turns to viral recipes, and the answers suggest that “strange” depends a lot on when and where you encountered a dish. Chicken baked in pineapple is real: a 1970s Bon Appétit recipe called for two whole pineapples and one and a half diced broiled chickens, reflecting the era’s enthusiasm for Hawaiian and luau themed food. Pistachio mashed potatoes, by contrast, are made up. Candied cucumbers with vanilla whipped cream and almonds are real, served in a parfait glass. Then comes the viral or vile round. Tacos in a bag get an immediate yes from the group, with Jesse’s Illinois roots offered as explanation. Crispy pan toasted glazed doughnuts also sound appealing, even if Jesse says he probably wouldn’t make them. The final prompt is dill pickle sparkling water; the fragment ends before anyone gives a verdict.