Thanksgiving pies for the people already eyeing dessert

Some diners save room for cheesecake. Others are ready for pie before the turkey’s cleared. This collection is for the second group—with whipped cream
within reach. The familiar choices are here: pumpkin, pecan, and apple in both double-crust and cinnamon-crumble form. But the more unusual pies make the list interesting: cranberry meringue with lime-bright curd, butterscotch custard under toasted marshmallow, and a pecan cream pie stacked with layers. There are chilled chocolate pies and citrus custards, too. A few could plausibly become breakfast the next day. The range matters. A holiday dessert table doesn’t need one consensus pick; it needs options for the person who wants a classic slice and the person who wants something a little less expected. For more ideas, browse our favorite pie recipes and more Thanksgiving desserts. If pastry is the sticking point, see our guide to making better pie or the roundup of best store-bought pie crusts.

Start with the classics

BA’s Best Pumpkin Pie pairs silky, warmly spiced custard with a flaky, buttery crust. Maple syrup and vanilla add depth, and the recipe has won over some pumpkin-pie skeptics. The photo is by Isa Zapata, with food styling by Judy Kim and prop styling by Beth Pakradooni. Bourbon Caramel Apple Pie puts Honeycrisp apples beneath a lattice crust, with smoky burnt-sugar caramel and bourbon in the filling. Give it time to cool before slicing. The photo is by Travis Rainey; Maggie Ruggiero handled food styling and Adrian Ababović prop styling. The props include the East Fork Spun Iron Pie Dish. Then there’s BA’s Best Pecan Pie. One reader, signing off as “Gramma” from Chattanooga, Tennessee, called it the best pecan pie recipe she’d ever used after many years of baking. That’s a strong endorsement from someone who’s made plenty of pies. The photograph is by Isa Zapata, with food styling by Emilie Fosnocht.

Fruit and spice bring the sharp edges

The cranberry meringue pie is the most striking of this group, and its balance depends on contrast: tart cranberry-lime curd under a soft, sweet meringue. Give it a night to set before serving; rushing that rest risks a filling that won’t hold its shape. Get the Cranberry Meringue Pie recipe.

A sliced cranberry meringue pie in a spun iron pie dish.
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Maggie Ruggiero, Prop Styling by Adrian Ababović. Props provided by East Fork, including the East Fork Spun Iron Pie Dish.

For a more familiar route, BA’s Best Apple Pie gets depth from reduced cider, vanilla, and cardamom. Claire Saffitz’s recipe calls for Pink Lady apples, whose sweet-tart flavor suits the filling; other apples for baking and pie can work too. The deep-dish format and golden double crust make this a substantial centerpiece. View the recipe.

Overhead view of a deep-dish apple pie with a golden-brown double crust.
Photo by Michael Graydon + Nikole Herriot.

Pecan pie, with extra layers

Pecan Cream Pie takes the classic nut filling in a richer direction: chopped pecans, brown sugar custard, tangy whipped cream, then candied pecans on top. That’s a lot of texture in one slice, and the whipped cream’s acidity gives the sweetness somewhere to go. View the recipe.

A pecan cream pie with layers of gooey chopped pecans, brown sugar custard, and whipped cream topped with candied pecans.
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Thu Buser, Prop Styling by Linden Elstran.

Two pies worth saving room for

The strongest finish here is a choice between rich spectacle and fruit forward restraint. Detroit’s Sister Pie supplies the spectacle: its [Toasted Marshmallow Butterscotch Pie](https://www.bonappetit.com/recipe/toasted-marshmallow-butterscotch-pie) layers flaky pastry, dark chocolate ganache and salty sweet butterscotch custard under homemade marshmallow toasted to golden peaks. It takes work. The payoff sounds worth it. Image may contain File BinderJesse David Green · 7/31 Then there’s [Pear Pie With Lattice Crust](https://www.bonappetit.com/recipe/epi-syn-pear-pie-with-lattice-crust), a classic *Gourmet* dessert that makes a persuasive Thanksgiving case for pears. Use firm-ripe Anjou or Bartlett pears, add a little nutmeg, and let the flaky lattice do the rest. Apple pie can stay on the menu too; there’s room for both. A lattice crust pear pie in a pie plate with a server.Photo by Joseph De Leo, food styling by Drew Aichele · 8/31