
This week in books
This week’s strongest reviews span Louise Kennedy’s intimate fiction and a fresh look at J. R. R. Tolkien’s life. Critics also turn to Judi Dench’s anecdotes, Dan Jones’s history of castles, and Simon Garfield’s account of the pen’s place in an age shaped by digital communication. The subjects are disparate, but the books share an interest in how people make meaning: through memory, place, history, performance and the marks they leave on a page.
Review counts offer a quick guide to the critical response, though they don’t tell you what a book will mean to every reader. The descriptions below give more useful clues: tone, method and the questions each title seems to raise. Here’s the thing: a high tally can point you toward a consensus, while a sharply described strength can help you decide whether that consensus matters to you.
Fiction with staying power
Louise Kennedy’s Stations leads the fiction selections with nine rave reviews. Cory Oldweiler of The Boston Globe calls it “extraordinary—and indeed bittersweet,” praising the lived-in perspective of Kennedy’s writing and placing her alongside Irish writers Eimear McBride and Sally Rooney. That comparison gives readers a sense of the novel’s literary company, while the praise for its intimate perspective points to the closeness of its emotional focus. Riverhead publishes the novel.
Tom Drury’s West of Loveland, from Grove Press, earned five rave and one positive review. Booklist’s Bill Kelly highlights its measured pace and the way its connected lives build into a humane reflection on fate and belonging. The emphasis on pace suggests a novel that lets relationships accumulate rather than forcing each one toward a quick revelation. That patient approach can be a strength when a book’s larger concerns emerge through the ties among its characters.
Ian Rankin’s The Heights received three rave, three positive and one mixed review. The novel takes Rankin beyond Edinburgh, but Chris Connor of Crime Fiction Lover says it retains the qualities that have sustained the Rebus books, with the author still finding new ground after four decades as a leading storyteller. A change of setting can test whether a writer’s strengths depend on familiar surroundings; Connor’s assessment suggests Rankin’s command of character and storytelling travels with him. Cardinal is the publisher.
Kit de Waal’s Sweet Pea drew four rave and one positive review. For Booklist’s Enobong Tommelleo, the book’s quiet humor and Caribbean phrases give warmth to a story of forgiveness that avoids sentimentality. That balance matters: forgiveness can flatten into a tidy moral if a story presses too hard for uplift, while humor and voice can keep its emotional stakes grounded.
Lucy Apps’s Gloria Don’t Speak, also recognized by Booklist, received two rave and one positive review. Laura Chanoux praises Apps’s precise handling of Gloria’s point of view and the character study’s lingering effect. The focus on perspective signals a book whose impact depends on how closely readers are brought into one person’s experience. Quietly observed character work. (And this is the part most people overlook: a story’s restraint can leave more room for readers to interpret what a character can’t say.)
Nonfiction’s varied subjects
D. J. Taylor’s The King Under the Mountain: In Search of J. R. R. Tolkien tops the nonfiction group, with five rave, one positive and three mixed reviews. Taylor moves away from conventional biography to offer a shorter, more irreverent account of Tolkien, while examining the contradictions behind his life and work. The Financial Times’ Marcel Theroux describes it as deeply researched and attentive to both Tolkien’s eccentricities and his gifts. The mixed responses alongside the praise suggest that an unconventional approach may not suit every reader seeking a full, conventional life story. Pegasus publishes the book; an excerpt is available here.
Judi Dench’s Is It Too Late to Make a Run for It? earned five rave reviews. Fiona Sturges of The Guardian points to the book’s loose structure and show-business anecdotes, saying Dench’s humor and warmth keep it moving. A memoir built around anecdotes depends on more than the events recalled: voice and timing determine whether familiar backstage material feels vivid or merely dutiful. Sturges’s praise suggests Dench’s personality supplies the momentum. The memoir is published by St. Martin’s.
Dan Jones’s Castles: A Fortified History of the World, from Viking, received four rave and one positive review. In The New York Times Book Review, Spencer Strub praises its account of how castle mythology, historical research and physical evidence intersect. That combination gives the subject more than a military frame: castles are structures people study, stories people tell and objects that survive to be examined. The book’s appeal appears to come from showing how those different forms of evidence inform one another.
Simon Garfield’s The Pen: A Human History earned three rave and two positive reviews. Booklist’s Lillian Liao sees the book as a history of the values people attach to writing by hand, as much as an examination of the object itself. That distinction broadens the subject from tools to habits and meaning: handwriting can carry personal associations that a description of the pen alone wouldn’t capture. If you’re working in this space, the book’s framing offers a useful reminder that everyday objects are often best understood through the practices built around them.
Mark Binelli’s Just a Shot Away: Martin Scorsese’s Life in Film rounds out the nonfiction list with four rave reviews. David Pitt of Booklist describes a portrait of Scorsese as a focused artist, offering a quieter view than the filmmaker’s familiar public persona. That perspective puts the emphasis on creative discipline and the work itself, rather than celebrity as a subject. Metropolitan publishes the book.
What the reviews suggest
The week’s selections show how varied a book’s route to praise can be. Some reviews respond to voice and character; others value research, structure or the way an author connects objects to wider human habits. The counts provide a starting point, but the specific critical judgments are more revealing: they show what a book asks readers to notice.
This is more significant than it looks. Across fiction and nonfiction, the strongest descriptions here focus on method—how a writer handles perspective, evidence, memory or pace. That said, critical enthusiasm can only sketch a book’s appeal. The sharper question for readers is whether the quality reviewers identify is the one they want from their next read.