Taika Waititi’s Instagram response to the reviews of Klara and the Sun says more about the distance between filmmakers and critics than it does about the film’s quality. The director dismissed critics as “irrelevant,” “out of touch” and “obsolete,” casting them as failed artists who resent the people making the work. That’s a familiar defense. What makes it telling is how easily it turns a disagreement over a movie into a claim that criticism itself has no value.

Waititi posted the remarks as Klara and the Sun struggled to draw audiences in its second weekend. He said he hadn’t read reviews of his work, or his peers’ work, in nearly 15 years, but nevertheless argued that critics had also disliked Jojo Rabbit. The evidence complicates that charge: the Oscar-winning film holds an 81 percent score on Rotten Tomatoes. More to the point, critics aren’t a single bloc with a shared verdict. The reviewer whose account prompted this essay says they disliked Jojo Rabbit, but had praised Waititi’s earlier films, including Hunt for the Wilderpeople, What We Do in the Shadows and Eagle vs. Shark.

A reaction that erases the record

Waititi’s post treats criticism as a personal grievance and critics as interchangeable antagonists. That framing leaves little room for the complicated history between a filmmaker and the people who write about his work. Many critics championed Waititi’s early features; their coverage helped those smaller New Zealand films find audiences beyond their home market. His claim that critics are simply resentful outsiders overlooks that support, as well as the fact that no reviewer’s response to one film predicts their response to another.

The author of the source piece makes clear that they haven’t seen Klara and the Sun. Their reservations stem from admiration for Kazuo Ishiguro’s novel, which they feared might not suit the sensibility of the director behind Jojo Rabbit. That distinction matters: the argument isn’t that the film deserves its reviews, or that Waititi should have made a different adaptation. It’s that a director’s frustration with critical reception doesn’t make criticism pointless, and attacking critics as a class obscures the specific judgments they make.

Artists have long bristled at criticism, sometimes in spectacularly personal ways. Vincent Gallo insulted Roger Ebert after Ebert criticized The Brown Bunny. Uwe Boll challenged critics to boxing matches and fought five who accepted. Pauline Kael’s reviews provoked strong reactions from Clint Eastwood and David Lean. These confrontations unfolded around identifiable critics and particular work. Today, public complaints more often target an anonymous category: “the critics,” set against “the fans.” That shift makes it easier to dismiss a judgment without engaging with what it says.

Online exposure changes the stakes

There are sound reasons for artists to avoid reading every review or social media reaction. The internet makes criticism hard to keep in proportion. A negative review can sit beside personal attacks, dogpiles and comments from strangers who have no interest in discussing the work. For anyone with a public profile, opening an app can mean confronting a stream of hostility that has little to do with thoughtful criticism.

That environment can make emotional distance feel necessary. But it also encourages a blunt form of self-protection: treat everyone outside the circle of supporters as hostile, and the criticism becomes easier to ignore. The cost is that thoughtful, specific responses disappear into the same category as online abuse. Critics become faceless sources of pain rather than people whose work can be assessed, challenged or even welcomed.

Marketing has helped normalize this divide. The campaign for Gotti, for example, asked audiences whether they trusted themselves or “a troll behind a keyboard,” after claiming critics had attacked the film. That pitch turns a question about a movie into a contest between ordinary viewers and a supposedly cynical press. It appeals to the idea that popularity proves critics wrong, even when audience scores and critical reviews measure different responses.

Waititi’s post follows the same logic. By suggesting that critics disliked Klara and the Sun because they failed to become artists, he offers a motive in place of an argument. It’s a tidy story, but one that turns dissent into evidence of the dissenter’s inadequacy. The more often public figures use that explanation, the harder it becomes to distinguish a bad review from a personal attack.

What criticism has lost

The weakening position of arts journalism feeds the problem. Critics once had a larger place in public culture. Writers such as Gore Vidal, James Baldwin and Norman Mailer appeared on television and panel shows as public intellectuals, not merely as contributors to a promotional cycle. Their judgments could carry weight, and a dispute between a critic and an artist could read as an argument between public figures with comparable standing.

That world has faded. Many critics now work for modest pay, and their reviews are frequently reduced to numbers in an aggregator. Those scores can be useful as a rough index of reception, but they flatten differences in argument and taste. A thoughtful review becomes one data point among many, while the critic’s reasoning is easy to overlook. That system gives filmmakers plenty of reasons to resent the shorthand, even as it makes the work of criticism less visible.

The imbalance of attention and resources is hard to miss. A successful filmmaker can reach a vast audience with one post; critics, including prominent ones, often have far less reach and financial security. Calling journalists obsolete in that setting doesn’t land as a fair exchange between peers. It sounds like a powerful person dismissing a smaller, less powerful profession for doing the job of evaluating public work.

Room for a more human exchange

Waititi isn’t the only filmmaker to lash out at negative reviews, and the digital pressures around public life affect artists as well as critics. Aaron Sorkin’s more self-effacing response to reviews of The Social Reckoning offers one example of a different tone. The contrast raises a useful question: whether a person’s habits of engaging with criticism depend partly on the Hollywood culture in which they came up. It doesn’t excuse Waititi’s broadside, but it does help explain how artists can lose sight of the people on the other side of the screen.

Ishiguro’s novel, which Waititi adapted, considers the distance people create as they seek ways to manage loneliness. One of its lines reflects on the “complex and hard to fathom” ways people act in response to that isolation. The source essay reads Waititi’s post through that idea: an attempt to protect oneself from criticism can become a complicated act of rejection, directed at people whose opinions might otherwise have mattered.

The practical takeaway for filmmakers is straightforward: ignoring reviews can be a reasonable boundary, but writing off critics as failed artists is a poor substitute for that boundary. It shrinks a varied body of opinion into a convenient enemy and overlooks the people who may have supported the work before its latest stumble. For audiences, the exchange is a reminder to look beyond scorekeeping and ask what a review actually argues. That’s where the conversation about a film begins.