November’s Bake Club Takes on Three Thanksgiving Pies

Thanksgiving dessert is a high-stakes part of the meal, and this month Bon Appétit’s Bake Club gives you three ways to handle it: a showy cranberry meringue, a bourbon caramel apple pie, and a salted coffee custard that skips rolling dough altogether. That range is the point. You can practice pastry technique, bring a classic to the table, or choose the easier route and still serve something made from scratch.

Bon Appétit senior editors and Test Kitchen bakers Jesse Szewczyk and Shilpa Uskokovic host the club for anyone who likes baking—or simply likes eating what comes out of the oven. Each month, they publish a tested recipe and invite readers to bake along, trade photos, ask questions, and share successes and mishaps. The ambition is practical: help people become more confident bakers while making the process part of the fun.

How to bake along

Start by saving a recipe and making it. The club also has a Substack chat, where Jesse and Shilpa share more about how recipes are developed. Post your results on Instagram with #BABakeClub, or leave feedback and questions in the Recipe Notes section of the recipe page in the Epicurious app; the editors say they read every comment.

You can also send baking questions to [email protected] for a chance to be featured on the podcast. Episodes tied to each recipe appear at the start of the following month on the Bon Appétit podcast feed.

November 2026: Thanksgiving pies

A salted coffee custard pie, cranberry meringue pie, and bourbon caramel apple pie in East Fork pie tins.
Photo by Travis Rainey; food styling by Maggie Ruggiero; prop styling by Adrian Ababović. Props provided by East Fork. The Salted Coffee Custard Pie (left) is baked in the East Fork Ceramic Pie Plate; the Cranberry Meringue Pie (bottom) and Bourbon Caramel Apple Pie (right) are baked in the East Fork Spun Iron Pie Dish.

The centerpiece is a pie crust Bon Appétit first published in 2022. The editors describe it as flaky enough to rival a croissant, and say it’s now the only pie dough used in the Test Kitchen—a meaningful endorsement from a room full of professional cooks. This month, it supports two very different bakes.

Cranberry Meringue Pie uses a single crust and puts blind baking to work beneath a tall, dramatic topping. Bourbon Caramel Apple Pie goes in the opposite direction: a lattice top and a second layer of pastry surround fruit coated in bourbon caramel. If making dough from scratch sounds like one task too many, the Salted Coffee Custard Pie uses a press-in oatmeal crust, silky coffee custard, and a light cap of mascarpone whipped cream.

That spread makes the November lineup more useful than a single showpiece recipe. You can choose the amount of pastry work you want to take on and still arrive at a pie suited to the holiday table.


October 2026: Salt Bread

Salt Bread rolls sit in two columns on a metal baking sheet, topped with coarse salt; one roll is cut open.
Photograph by Isa Zapata; food styling by Maggie Ruggiero; prop styling by Christine Keely.

Salt bread—called shio pan in Japan and sogeum-ppang in Korea—borrows the soft character of a Parker House roll and milk bread, with flaky layers reminiscent of a French croissant. A piece of salted butter is wrapped inside each bun; as it melts, it pools beneath the dough and crisps the bottom. Deputy food editor Hana Asbrink’s preferred way to eat one is to pull it apart, enjoy the hollow buttery middle, then peel back its layers. —Hana Asbrink, deputy food editor

Make the recipe


September 2026: Apple Pie Fritters

Glazed apple fritters, including one broken open to show its apple filling, on a bright yellow background.
Photograph by Elliott Jerome Brown Jr.; prop styling by Linden Elstran; food styling by Kaitlin Wayne.

These fritters aim for the farm-stand payoff of an apple-picking trip: warm, apple-filled dough with cinnamon sugar and a little fried richness. The recipe gets there without asking you to wait for yeast dough to rise.

August 2026: Plum Cheesecake Karpatka

A slice of plum cheesecake karpatka on a plate.

Karpatka gets its name from the Carpathian Mountains, whose ridges its craggy pastry layers are said to resemble. The traditional Polish cake sandwiches pastry cream, sometimes enriched with whipped cream or made as crème mousseline, between two airy rounds of pâte à choux. This August version takes a playful turn: a no-bake cheesecake filling, streaked with homemade plum jam, sits between the pastry layers. Make it ahead, then bring a little more summer to the table.

Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Micah Marie Morton, Prop Styling by Adrian Ababović

Make the Recipe

July 2026: Sweet Corn-Coconut Crunch Butter Mochi

Several stacks of sweet corncoconut crunch butter mochi cake squares.

The appeal here is texture as much as flavor. Fresh or frozen corn and sweetened condensed milk give this sunny cake its base, while sweet rice flour supplies its signature chew. The result has a gentle spring and slight elasticity, with buttered-corn flavor, toasted coconut, and a nutty caramel edge. It’s a vivid midsummer Bake Club pick, and frozen corn means you don’t have to wait for peak season.

Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Thu Buser, Prop Styling by Alexandra Massillon

Make the Recipe

June 2026: Tiny Tomato Galettes

A round of flaky pastry topped with a sliced heirloom tomato chives and dill on a plate.

Think of these as the best parts of a tomato sandwich and a pie, folded into individual servings. Black pepper seasons the pie dough, which bakes into crisp, distinct layers without special equipment. A garlicky Parmesan-herb mayonnaise goes underneath each tomato slice, helping shield the pleated pastry from the tomato’s moisture. It’s a small, practical bit of engineering that keeps the crust delicate rather than soggy.

Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Micah Marie Morton, Prop Styling by Alexandra Massillon

—Rebecca Firkser, Test Kitchen editor

Make the Recipe

May 2026: Whole Lemon Bars

Three lemon bars dusted with confectioner's sugar one with a bite taken out.

Using the whole lemon gives these bars a sharper, more layered flavor than juice and zest alone can offer. Two lemons are blitzed into the curd, then strained to remove the pulp; the pith’s bitterness and the peel’s essential oils stay in the mix alongside the juice’s acidity. The effect leans toward Lemonhead candy. If you like a restrained lemon bar, this probably isn’t your recipe. If you want the classic turned up loud, it makes its case.

Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Kaitlin Wayne, Prop Styling by Emma Ringness

Get the Recipe

April 2026: Strawberry Shortcake Roll

A cutinto strawberry swiss roll on a white platter seen from above.

This cake earned its place in Bake Club after an informal test: it was made for deputy food editor Hana Asbrink’s birthday the year before and quickly won over the room. Fluffy cake, vanilla-speckled cream, and juicy strawberries make an easy argument for repeating the success. The usual fear with a roll cake is cracking during shaping. Here, an oil-based chiffon sponge keeps the process forgiving, so you can roll it without a complicated sequence or a broken cake. It’s a fitting spring dessert, especially alongside tender asparagus.

Photograph by Elliott Jerome Brown Jr., Food Styling by Micah Morton, Prop Styling by Christina Allen

Get the Recipe

March 2026: Chocolate Guinness Cake

A chocolate loaf cake made with Guinness stout and topped with brown butter frosting cut in half.

After February’s savory detour, Bake Club returns to dessert with a chocolate loaf built around Guinness stout. The stout brings a malty depth, while the notably tender crumb comes from reverse creaming: rub butter by hand into the dry ingredients until it nearly disappears, then continue with the batter. That step limits gluten development, and it doesn’t call for a stand mixer. The method is simple; the texture payoff is the point.

Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Kaitlin Wayne, Prop Styling by Sean Dooley

Get the Recipe

February 2026: Cheddar Biscuits With Old Bay

Image may contain Food Food Presentation Bread Blade Knife and Weapon

Elliott Jerome Brown Jr.

Cheddar Biscuits With Old Bay

A hot, layered biscuit can deliver the same comfort as homemade bread with far less time and work. This version folds in plenty of cheese and Old Bay; a quick lamination gives the dough its tall, flaky layers. You don’t need special gear, though a [bench scraper](https://www.amazon.com/Ateco-Bench-Scraper-Wood-Handle/dp/B000KEYDHW/ref=sr_1_1?crid=1KVJK2U25NS5M&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.Bw1EsDUQuHngyJToi6GzOWonf2K8UxIQsOMmyKVImTqm7Zdb5NWgKuMmH12iGZZEjyRIYulpiX7-515zsk2LpFzpYKLkXNGgRHuvLISK0PtRBkkq81iCz9Si-dQ1SM1qJAh9XVr9K-nwX8r_BqazxuzVFbGaMG9D2byAZx7MpO-l9K9ydXEkjJ9jHbGikdJ7IGyHawXACLlboOsRx9tqvgKap9EZm2Bhpx91miQUki_lXLEbCWDbDR4CcAYl_R47Rx6fSNZhSufwKJ0lA5Zm1P_J-Db7EYmBGUZJ_Cg5xh4.T-jlaGQip1xgQOLT-C0VydWpSUY8yqtrPZDkm-RJOaA&dib_tag=se&keywords=ateco%2Bbench%2Bscraper&qid=1769471858&s=home-garden&sprefix=ateco%2Bbench%2Bscraper%2Cgarden%2C116&sr=1-1&th=1) makes shaping easier. Chris recently gave me a set from [Gestura](https://gesturautensils.com/products/flexi-dough-scraper); its compact size, sturdy build, curved edges, and simple handle have made it a favorite. For the folding method, see [this guide to laminated biscuits](https://www.bonappetit.com/story/how-to-fold-for-laminated-biscuits). If you’re deciding what to bake, this is a persuasive case for biscuits over a long bread project. Make the recipe

January 2026: Homemade Bagels

A bagel with furikake topping and cream cheese spread on a plate.
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Jesse Szewczyk, Prop Styling by Linden Elstran
A dozen chewy bagels from pantry staples is a strong return on a little time. Their texture comes from a simple two-stage bake: boil first, then bake, for a glossy, browned crust and a dense interior that stays tender rather than tough. The topping is yours to choose; furikake, Parmesan, sesame seeds, and flaky salt are all favorites. That flexibility is part of the appeal: the method gives you the classic bagel texture, while the finish can go in any direction. Make the recipe

December 2025: Cherry and Chocolate Pavlova

A meringue crust with chocolate ganache and marshmallow layers topped with frozen dark cherries shaved chocolate and...
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Shilpa Uskokovic and Jesse Szewczyk, Prop Styling by Linden Elstran
This pavlova takes its cue from Black Forest cake, with chocolate, cream, cherries, and kirsch. That combination has traveled well beyond its Bavarian roots—including to India, Fiji, the Philippines, and the Caribbean. For the author, it also recalls a bakery in Chennai, where they grew up: their parents brought home tall triangular slices when school tests went well. Pavlovas can crack, weep, or turn soggy, so the sugar-to-white ratio matters. Two parts sugar to one part egg whites by weight produces a crisp, sturdy, snow-white shell. The technique is precise; the result leaves room for a generous, celebratory dessert. Make the recipe

November 2025: Giant, Gooey Cinnamon Roll

A giant cinnamon bun on a wire rack covered in icing.
Photo by Travis Rainey, Food Styling by Shilpa Uskokovic, Prop Styling by Linden Elstran
The point of this oversized roll is to maximize the sticky center, often the best part of the pastry. Instant vanilla pudding stirred into cinnamon sugar helps create that familiar mall-style gooey filling, thanks to its modified food starch. It’s large enough to slice like a cake. But if you’d rather pull it apart by hand, that’s probably the right call. Make the recipe

October 2025: Chocolate Chip Cookies With Olive Oil and Sea Salt