The search for a biological father begins with a face that seems to answer the question—and a man who says it doesn’t. In this excerpt from This Vital Absence by Sophia Veltfort, Sylvia tries to make sense of a possible connection to Dean Nagler, an anesthesiologist linked in news coverage to a famous pop star’s death. What makes the encounter unsettling isn’t only the uncertainty of her paternity. It’s how quickly Sylvia recognizes Dean’s flaws, and how much she wants to recognize herself in them.

A face that looks like an answer

Dean posts videos about the famous musicians he knew during his heyday: Eric Clapton, Frank Zappa, Pink Floyd, The Who. On camera, he sits in a home office among bird statuettes, leaning toward the lens as his eyebrows rise and his voice surges. Sylvia sees his hunger for admiration and recognizes something uncomfortably familiar in it. A commenter calls him an idiot. He has lost his medical license after administering anesthesia while high on fentanyl, lives in upstate New York, and may have played a role in a pop star’s death. He also has Sylvia’s chin and eyelids.

In the summer of 2014, after returning to New York from a UK postgraduate fellowship, Sylvia receives a packet from her mothers, Celeste and Lucia. They’ve assembled what she calls the “Dean Dossier”: a 2009 CNN interview, a Google Books acknowledgment with a nurse’s name highlighted, articles from the late 1980s and early 1990s, local reporting about the anesthesiologist on a pop star’s 1997 World Tour, and emails with their fertility doctor after his 2006 release from prison for insurance fraud. There’s also a scan of a sketch Sylvia already knows—a young man in profile who resembles Dean. Her mothers think they may have found the name Sylvia has wanted: her father’s.

Dean is easy to find online. After losing his license, he volunteers at a bird sanctuary and fills his free time recalling his work with celebrities. His Facebook page promises, I respond to most messages within two hours. Sylvia clicks on a random video, a seven-minute, thirty-nine-second talk about The Who. For years, she’s searched men’s faces for some trace of herself. With Dean, she doesn’t need to search.

That resemblance carries more weight because Sylvia has spent so long trying to perform reliability and goodness while feeling that both are a façade. Reading about Dean’s recklessness, she imagines the intoxicated confidence of working while high and going uncaught. She recognizes the appeal of feeling invincible. His apparent capacity for dissolution offers her an unexpected relief: perhaps she comes from someone who shares the chaos she has tried to hide.

The first message

Before she can talk herself out of it, Sylvia sends Dean a Facebook message: her mother was a patient of Dr. Nielson in 1989, she’s looking for the sperm donor, and she wants to know whether Dean ever donated. She signs it “Sylvia F.”

Her roommate, Tom, is already getting ready for a housewarming party. He works at McKinsey and, despite Sylvia’s assumption that he studied economics, his academic work was about Marxist influences on the American administrative state during the New Deal. Sylvia tutors online and is considering more school. They share an apartment because it suits them both; their relationship is friendly, sometimes flirtatious, but not quite a friendship.

On the elevator ride to a party near Sylvia’s former high school, Dean replies: he worked with Dr. Nielson, but never donated sperm. He hopes she finds what she’s looking for. Sylvia tells Tom, “My dad reached out to me.” When he points out that she’d said she didn’t have a father, she answers, “I didn’t, but it’s him all right.” She describes Dean as mostly pathetic, with a few redeeming comic features. Tom doubts she really believes that.

At the party, Sylvia tells Tom about the dossier and the suspicion that her father may have been involved in a pop star’s death. She wonders whether to write again. Tom advises her not to insist that she’s Dean’s child. That’s precisely the fantasy Sylvia has been entertaining: to write a letter so compelling that Dean would have to recognize her as his brilliant offspring. She says she probably won’t respond, then changes her mind on the way home.

Her second message praises Dean’s videos about Duane Allman and the Fillmore East, then tells him he seems able to negotiate the competing parts of himself. Sylvia admits that she feels as though her identity and her desires keep rewriting each other. The message is a calculated appeal to Dean’s vanity, and she knows it. By the time she and Tom reach home, Dean hasn’t answered. Maybe he didn’t donate, she says. Maybe his reply was a mistake.

Tom thinks Dean is lying: the insurance fraud and fentanyl, he says, suggest Dean could have had reason to hide what he did. He looks at Sylvia, then at Dean’s Facebook page, and tells her, “But he’s definitely your dad.” The confidence is striking. The evidence, at this point, remains circumstantial.

Another possible family story

The next morning, Sylvia wakes in Tom’s bed and imagines having someone she can confide in about both men. Her former college roommate, once her model for how to be a woman in the world, has mostly stopped speaking to her. Tom jokes that he had to carry Sylvia home and calls himself “incredibly chivalrous.” By the time Sylvia makes coffee, Dean has sent another message: he advises her to “be all of them,” arguing that a person needn’t choose a single identity and can rearrange themselves with ingenuity and stubbornness.

Sylvia’s neighbor Molly has her own uncertainty about where she belongs. The two first met when Sylvia moved in: Molly offered help with a houseplant, explained that she still had a spare key to the apartment, and proposed trading keys in case either of them got locked out. Since then, they’ve crossed paths doing laundry and watching the same medical show. Molly sometimes leaves Sylvia small gifts after locking herself out—a cupcake, popcorn, once a yo-yo. Sylvia thinks of her as a wild crow that exchanges treasures.

Weeks after the party, Molly says both her sisters sent her DNA tests because they suspect she was switched at birth. She says hospital mix-ups happen more often than people think, citing her sister’s estimate of about one in a thousand; most are caught within days, but some surface years later, sometimes after a father questions whether a child is his. Molly offers Sylvia the spare test. They could spit into the cups, learn about their ancestry, and drink wine together. “It’ll be a date.”

For Sylvia, a DNA test means more than a chance to trace ancestry. Her unknown father has been a long-running source of speculation. Her mothers passed along the fertility doctor’s description: Tall. Slim. Wavy brown hair. Doctor or medical student. Eastern European. Jewish. Young. Sylvia also has the yellowing carbon-paper sketch her mother drew after seeing a man at the clinic who seemed to fit. From those scraps, she has imagined countless possible fathers over twenty-four years. An online woman named Adelaide once seemed like a possible half-sister, but the exchange went nowhere. Now there’s Dean.

The theory connecting Dean to Sylvia rests on a chain of clues. Her mothers saw a young man with a short ponytail enter a side room at the fertility clinic and emerge five minutes later smiling. The nurse reportedly said the donor was an anesthesiologist. Dean was an anesthesiologist, and Sylvia believes he’s the man in her mother’s sketch, based on images from CNN interviews after the pop star’s death. The timing adds another complication: in 1989, health departments began requiring clinics to use frozen sperm, a rule some clinics resisted because they believed freezing reduced effectiveness. The clues point in a direction. They don’t settle the question.

Tom thinks taking Molly’s test may be foolish, though he tells Sylvia she might as well do it if she can avoid getting carried away. Then he asks whether she expects to be attracted to her “billions of half-brothers and -sisters.” Sylvia takes a beat before answering: “That is disgusting.”

What starts as a question about DNA turns into something harder to measure: the narrator’s growing attachment to Molly, and the possibility that curiosity can become its own kind of intimacy. Tom looks up genetic sexual attraction on his phone and reports that it occurs in fifty percent of reunions between close relatives meeting as adults. I ask if he’s worried about consensual incest. He says no. He’s fascinated. Then he takes his plate to the table and covers it in hot sauce.


Molly answers the door in a black silk jumpsuit, cream buttons, and leopard loafers. Her apartment looks like a delivery depot collided with a laundry pile. Amazon boxes stack by the entrance; sweaters and scarves cover the kitchen chairs. My gray sweatpants sit on the counter beside a houseplant shriveled to the size of a fist.

“It’s all my roommate’s,” Molly says, taking two shot glasses from a cupboard and a half-full tequila bottle from atop the fridge. The DNA kit says not to eat or drink for an hour before giving a sample, she explains, so we should have shots, eat chocolate milk balls, and put something on TV first. Then we can spit into the tubes and open the wine I brought. I’d followed her instructions and avoided food and drink. I set the bottle beside the dying plant.

She gives me a lime, salt, and a blue serrated knife printed with silver vegetables. In the living room, two long couches face a television. I look at the framed movie posters: a 1951 Hitchcock film, two men wrestling, a woman, and railway tracks slicing through orange. On the shelves, the same smiling middle-aged couple appear in several photographs. Her parents, maybe. Or her roommate’s.

“Lick first,” Molly says, holding out the salt. “It won’t stick otherwise.” I lick the back of my hand. She shakes salt onto the damp spot and watches me.

After two rounds, I stop. Molly disappears and returns with a box rimmed in frost. She gives me a chocolate ball, eats one herself, and asks how long my roommate and I have been together.

“We’re not,” I say around the chocolate. The answer has become less true over the past few weeks. When Tom and I meet friends, we tend to find each other: his arm behind me at dinner, our knees touching in a taxi, my arm tucked into his beneath an umbrella, his thumb brushing my lower lip as we leave. We never discuss it. Before Molly can ask more, I ask why her sisters think she isn’t related to them.

“We’re nothing alike,” she says, then pauses. “You and I have more in common.”

That’s flimsy evidence. Apart from liking medical dramas, we share no obvious traits. Molly moves beside me on the couch and proposes a comparison. We press our palms together. Her hand is damp with lime juice and sweat.

“See?” she says, exhaling. “Exactly the same.”


Molly says she’ll send in the kits and tell me when the results arrive. She manages the whole process: checking the saliva level, adding the stabilizer, packing the samples. Four to six weeks, she says.

The next morning, I remember the mess at her place and start cleaning my own. I wash dishes, hang up clothes, and water the jade plant Molly brought over when I moved in. Fine white roots dangle from its lower branches like legs trying to stay afloat.

I liked Molly because she made intimacy feel both new and strangely familiar, like something I’d once possessed and lost—or never had, but wanted.

When I first woke in this apartment, I loved being answerable to nobody. From the windows in my bedroom and living room, I could see the building entrance; from my loft bed, I watched the crosstown bus bend around pedestrians. I grew up in New York. My old elementary school is sixteen blocks north. Besides my moms, I knew a few college friends, some Marshall Scholars, a handful of people from high school, and a couple of friends from kindergarten. During my first weeks back, I got in touch with some of them, sometimes with Tom and often without. We went to birthdays, readings, and happy hours. At expensive Greenwich Village bars, I bought drinks and nursed them in corners while making small talk so empty I stopped paying attention to it.

Molly offered a different kind of closeness. I liked her commitment to her own idea of herself, even if she hadn’t trusted me to follow the instruction about fasting before the test. I carried the rubbish downstairs. In the recycling room, a stack of unflattened boxes filled the bin. I pulled apart the smallest. There was one receipt inside, for two DNA kits. I searched for her sisters’ names. The billing and shipping addresses matched. The receipt said what it said: Molly had bought both kits herself.


Upstairs, I searched Molly online, working through her Facebook and Instagram. She grew up in Billings, Montana, went to Catholic school, then attended a small liberal arts college in Ohio. She had plenty of selfies from her computer: Molly at a desk that looked like it was in her childhood bedroom, dark hair untidy, head tilted; Molly in her dorm room, makeup bright, a Solo cup on the windowsill. I imagined her getting ready for a party with a vodka soda, lining her eyes. Her expression looked less nervous than defeated. Maybe she’d already gone out, stood at a party where nobody spoke to her, and felt loneliness closing in. Maybe she’d faked a phone call, slipped away, and opened Photo Booth in her room to figure out what she’d done wrong.

Why lie about her sisters sending her an extra test? I should have been more troubled by that. Maybe I would have been, if a thrilling possibility hadn’t begun to glow somewhere in my mind. Between tutoring boarding-school students over Skype and applying to PhD programs, I looked up everything I could find about Molly. I also wavered over Dean’s offer to let him know how it goes, and his suggestion that I rearrange myself a little. Molly had tried out for her high school swim team and quit after one season. She published a single film review in her college paper. A poem won an honorable mention in a literary contest run by a magazine that no longer exists. Someone with her name died in Westport, Connecticut, in 1887.

On weekday mornings, I sat beneath my loft bed and watched Molly turn left toward the coffee shop a block away. She ran in the same gray leggings and oversized sweatshirt. She didn’t shop for groceries in person. FreshDirect brought her perishables; Amazon delivered her garbage bags; her clothes came from a rotating list of online stores.

If my guess was right—and even if it wasn’t, I felt entitled to match her strange behavior with some of my own—I could take certain liberties. One morning, I followed her outside wearing a baseball cap decorated with marine mammals that I’d found in Tom’s closet. I’d barely left home for days. The weather had turned cold, the autumn air sharp with the feeling that something might happen.

At 96th and Broadway, a gray-haired woman with a little shopping cart raised her hand for a cab. Across the crossing, a gray-haired man holding four plastic bags of takeaway did the same. I couldn’t tell if they were competing strangers or traveling together. Molly was already heading into the coffee shop, so I hurried after her.

She ordered iced coffee with oat milk and a poppy-seed strudel. I admired how casually she studied the pastries, leaning backward for a better view. A woman behind me, pushing a baby carriage, asked if I was waiting to order.

“No,” I said, trying to explain why I was there as my heart knocked around. “I’m waiting for my sister.”

The pleasure that moved through me was so sharp that my armpits prickled.

Ever since I learned about the wavy-haired doctor—or medical student—who was probably my father, I’d assumed I had half-siblings. I’d always thought one of them might find me. Molly’s approach was bizarre, but I admired its nerve. She’d opened a story I could step into. Dean remained a mystery I didn’t know how to approach. The medical show Molly and I watched had finished, and I’d finally completed the nineteenth-century novel I’d been dragging through for months. Without those plots to organize my thoughts, the days had begun to feel empty. Now there was Molly, and whatever she wanted from me.

One evening, Tom came home to find me in a work blouse and pajama bottoms, scrolling through Molly’s photos from a Dublin holiday in 2007.

“Jesus,” he said. “Sylvia, take a shower. Put on pants. Go outside and get some air.”

I wished I hadn’t told him about Molly. I wished even more that I hadn’t shared the contents of my Dean Dossier, or admitted how much I’d thought about my father as a child. The sensation was the same. I used to imagine my father pouring cereal, buying a film ticket and popcorn, marking a book. I imagined Dean searching his kitchen for lost keys, spilling coffee, putting the kettle on. Now hours disappeared while I read Molly’s captions. Every person I tried to understand became a hole I could keep digging. I wanted to see more.

I’d thought I could take a quick look at Molly, just a toe over the edge of an old obsession. I’d forgotten how impossible it was to see the bottom, how completely my attention could reorganize itself around the need to know. As a child, I dreamed about an endless room of filing cabinets, every fact I wanted within reach. A name. A personality. A body. A mind with its preferences, its moods, its fingerprints. I pictured those details on four-by-six index cards, building my father one piece at a time. For what? So he’d love me? So he’d look at me and think I was impressive? So I could understand him well enough to wind him up and make him move?

With Molly, I could gather the details. Her Facebook and Instagram, her Twitter account, the search results. Photos of breakfast, makeup brushes she liked, dozens of pictures of her face. I could study how much it resembled mine. I could assemble a whole company of Mollies and give each one a role in whatever story I wanted to tell.

By the time I left home, I was wearing her black ankle socks. Over the past few weeks, I’d collected her abandoned laundry: a white tank top, a pillowcase, a cheap tote bag that had been trapped in the washing machine’s rubber seal. It came out wet and soapy, so I rinsed it before adding it to my clothes. I kept track of what I’d lost: two single crew socks, my crochet underwear, and leggings I sometimes wore while tutoring.

Molly hadn’t come back from work, but I followed her usual route to the coffee shop. In the softer evening light, the upside-down orange mugs looked quieter. I ordered iced coffee with oat milk. As the barista filled the cup with ice, I wondered if Molly avoided dairy because of lactose intolerance or the environment.

Let’s hang out, I texted. I wanted to add, I miss you, you little freak. I didn’t. She didn’t know I’d found out she bought both tests.

I can’t, she replied. I’m on a date.

Oh. Gotcha.

It’s going badly. She hasn’t laughed at any of my jokes.

Want me to rescue you? I wrote. As your [insert roommate/sister/lover/cat sitter], I have an emergency you need to attend to. My chest tightened as I listed the possibilities.

She didn’t answer for several minutes. I sat at the counter by the window, the metal stool cold through my jeans. Outside, a woman glanced around to see if anyone had noticed her poodle defecating among a tree’s roots. Apparently satisfied, she left the mess behind.

I knew Tom would understand if I found the right way to tell him. I could make it funny. He liked strange, unexpected things, especially when I seemed distant enough to joke about them. I liked that he believed I had distance and control. Really, I had turmoil, and the occasional luck to pull the right piece of myself out when I reached inside.

Yeah ok, Molly wrote. Come get me.

She sent the address.


The bar was one I’d passed but never entered. Arcade games crowded the room, beneath murals of naked women painted in aquamarine and violet. Molly waited by an ATM, dressed in a black turtleneck that turned translucent under the neon, a crimson skirt and matching heels. She held a plastic cup of clear liquid and sipped through a narrow pink straw.

A sandy-haired woman in a baseball cap and a Missoula sweatshirt stood with her. She was telling Molly about a bear she’d seen swimming. Every few strokes, the bear looked over at her and kept paddling.

“How big was it?” Molly asked.

“Pretty big,” the woman said, a little cautiously. Then she brightened. “I can show you the video.”

As the woman reached for her phone, I stepped in. Molly’s face lit up when she saw me. She looked me over, then said, “Carol. What are you doing here?”

“It’s the baby,” I said. “She’s sick.”

The woman frowned. “You have a baby?”

Molly solemnly nodded. “Our sister’s. She’s dead. She had a child.”

“Shit,” the woman said. “No dad in the picture?”

“Not a one,” Molly replied, her eyes bright. “Bye.”


We didn’t head home. Molly wanted to try a wine bar around the corner, but every table was occupied. The waiter brought chairs to an old radio console opposite the bar. I couldn’t settle beside it without twisting my back or straining my hip flexors. Molly leaned back and studied me.

“So,” she said. “Sister, rather than lover, cat sitter, or roommate.”

“It could’ve been our baby. We could’ve been married and divorced.”

“You wouldn’t have left it,” she said. “I still don’t know who you left it with.”

“It grew up.”

Molly traced a finger down the menu and ordered a gimlet. I chose prosecco.

“Are we celebrating?” she asked.

“I’d like to. What is there to celebrate?”

She looked at me. I wanted to ask what she thought we were doing. A few times, watching her leave the building, I’d wondered if she was looking up at my window. Now her eyes held mine. I wanted to know how she’d made sense of what she knew about me, and what she’d guessed.

Somewhere in all the facts I’d collected, my need to know her—to pour out the questions I’d been saving for a lifetime—had changed into something else. Something nearer to love.

The post I Might Sleep With My Neighbor, If She Isn’t My Half-Sister appeared first on Electric Literature.