

Best A24 Horror Movies, Ranked by Tomatometer
Updated: Two 2026 releases, Backrooms and Undertone, have been added to the list.
A24’s horror identity
A24’s reputation in horror rests on a useful distinction: Blumhouse built its name around lean budgets and broad audiences, while A24 became associated with films willing to make fear stranger, slower, and less predictable. Both companies rose during the 2010s, a decade that produced some of the genre’s most talked-about work. You can trace A24’s horror breakthrough to 2016, when Robert Eggers’ The Witch brought period detail and creeping dread, and Green Room turned a backwoods punk show into a brutal fight for survival. A24 also released the Best Picture Oscar winner Moonlight that year.
The company’s horror run kept building. Hereditary, released in 2018, was A24’s highest-grossing film until Everything Everywhere All at Once. It also launched writer-director Ari Aster’s feature career; he followed it with 2019’s blazing, unsettling Midsommar.
“Elevated horror” became a shorthand for films that put atmosphere, dread, and ideas ahead of jump scares. The label has faded, but the shift it described hasn’t: movies such as It Follows and Blumhouse’s Get Out helped widen expectations for what horror could do and still withstand critical and social scrutiny. A24 has continued that approach into the 2020s, from Rose Glass’ Saint Maud to Ti West’s X, Pearl, and MaXXXine, as well as Talk to Me. The ranking below puts those varied approaches in Tomatometer order.
The middle of this ranking makes a strong case for horror that gets under your skin in different ways: family secrets, claustrophobic danger, and the fear of what you can’t see. Audience scores are more divided than critics’ scores for several of these films, which suggests the list favors ambition and unease over easy crowd-pleasing.
Fear inside the home—and outside it
Hereditary and Green Room both sit at 90% with critics, but their threats come from opposite directions: one turns family history into a trap; the other makes immediate physical danger the whole point. That range matters. Horror doesn’t need one shared formula to earn critical approval.
Belief, grief, and things left unexplained
Here’s the split in the ratings: It Comes at Night earns 88% from critics but just 44% from audiences. That gap hints at a film whose restraint and ambiguity work better for reviewers than for viewers looking for clearer answers. The score alone can’t explain the response, but the contrast is hard to miss.
Strange premises, sharp turns
Strange worlds, difficult choices
The films ranked 17 through 20 share a taste for horror that lingers after the plot stops explaining itself. Their audience scores sit below their critics’ ratings, a reminder that unsettling imagery and ambiguity can divide viewers.
That’s the appeal—and the wager—of this stretch of the list: each film trusts atmosphere to do work that a tidy explanation might weaken. If you’re choosing one, expect an experience that may stay with you longer than its plot points.










