Maiden by Cynthia Buchanan, reissued by Hagfish.

Cynthia Buchanan’s Maiden understands that desire can be less about wanting another person than about watching yourself want one. Its heroine, Fortune Dundy, arrives in Los Angeles hoping for romance and success, but the novel’s real subject is the gap between those fantasies and the awkward, often grotesque business of living them. Hagfish’s reissue brings Buchanan’s only novel back into view as a nimble comedy that gradually darkens into something more disturbing.

A dating club with a thin line between fantasy and farce

First published by William Morrow in 1972, Maiden unfolds at Villa Dionysus, an adults-only apartment complex and social club for single people between twenty-five and forty. Its sales pitch promises community and sexual possibility. For Fortune, a thirty-year-old virgin, the place becomes a stage on which she can audition for the life she imagines: a suitable man, a successful career and a more glamorous version of herself.

The setting grows out of a particular moment in American culture. The sexual revolution had moved beyond the familiar language of liberation and into commercial spaces designed to sell access, atmosphere and companionship. Buchanan makes Villa Dionysus both a playground and a trap. Its residents pursue pleasure with the air of people following instructions, while Fortune moves through the scene as if she’s investigating a mystery.

That detective-story framing is one of the book’s funniest inventions. Fortune gives herself an imaginary confidant in Bert Parks, the real television host known for presiding over game shows and the Miss America pageant. In her private conversations, Bert becomes a crooning emcee, adviser and judge. He might tell her she looks “like a million dollars in mauve”; she might threaten to kill him if he’s lying.

The device suits a heroine who is both contestant and audience. Fortune wants to be chosen, but she also imagines herself being watched and evaluated. Her inner life borrows television’s rhythms: the entrance, the approving remark, the suspense of whether she’ll be selected. The fantasy of a man arriving to rescue her takes on the shape of a television miracle, a lover who steps out from behind the screen and into her life.

Sexual comedy with an undertow

Maiden uses physical comedy to expose how little Fortune’s romantic ideals match the men she encounters. Phil, an oaf she dates, is described as having an oddly shaped head and foul breath. During a beach encounter, he reaches his own climax and blurts out, “I just made a mess in my—oh, Gawd, I love you!” The joke lands because the scene reduces courtship to a clumsy performance in which the two people aren’t even playing the same game.

Skip Fritchey, a dentist and the ex-husband of Fortune’s roommate, Beverly “Biscuit” Besqueth, seems more promising. Fortune is drawn to him even as his body unsettles her. A scar he shows her prompts a fear that the wound might open, which becomes tangled with her own apprehension about sex. She thinks of “throbbing meat”; a glimpse of his pale thigh is enough to cool her interest.

This isn’t a simple tale of a woman waiting to become sexually experienced. Fortune’s attraction is real, but physical intimacy repels her. Buchanan lets that contradiction drive the comedy, then refuses to keep it safely comic. Fortune’s sexual encounters with brutish men are mishaps, but they also reveal how vulnerable she is inside a culture that treats dating as a routine everyone should know how to perform.

Biscuit offers a parallel, more theatrical response to that pressure. A divorcée who speaks in a babyish voice, she tries to reclaim a kind of maidenhood by behaving like a child. She calls her boyfriend “daddy” and asks him to kiss her until her lips bleed. Her role-playing is absurd, but Buchanan’s interest extends beyond ridicule: the characters use costumes and scripts to manage desires they can’t comfortably express directly.

Work becomes another performance

The book’s satire reaches past romance to the humiliations of finding a job. Villa Dionysus’s former stuntmen now work for the Highway Department; Fortune, who dismisses the idea of becoming a salesperson, ends up in sales herself. The workplace offers no clean escape from the sexualized world of the complex. It simply gives that world a different script.

Biscuit’s boyfriend Campbell, an advertising man, develops a Roman-themed commercial for a pudding campaign. He directs the models to admire and ogle the product for the camera. Fortune’s own job demonstrating cake decoration turns her into a salesperson for frosting, explaining the technique as she squeezes icing from a cloth bag. Buchanan makes the work funny, but the joke carries a sting: Fortune’s labor requires her to perform enthusiasm, charm and expertise for strangers.

She comes to enjoy the cake job, which makes its absurd indignity more telling. When she quits because she refuses to wear a hairnet, she insists that her hair is her glory. Later, missing the work, she cuts her hair and tries to return, only to discover that the demonstration company has moved south for the season. She’s left jobless and shorn, ready to take another degrading position.

That episode condenses the novel’s view of self-presentation. Fortune’s appearance is not a superficial detail pasted over her personality; it’s part of how she tries to build one. She stuffs her bra with tissue, wears a conspicuously bright hairpiece and decorates herself with feathers. She even alters her name to “Fortunée,” giving it what she calls a French accent. These flourishes can look ridiculous, but they also give her a way to imagine herself as someone with options.

A novel that turns watching into a trap

Buchanan’s prose shifts easily between slapstick, parody and melancholy. Her comic set pieces can be fizzy and jagged; elsewhere, she slows down and lets Fortune’s loneliness settle. The book’s plot can seem almost dormant, as if the heroine’s life is waiting for a cue. When events finally break loose, that patience gives the rupture its force.

Television offers Fortune a model for understanding the world and a way to avoid entering it. She doesn’t merely imagine an audience; she sees herself through one. On a coastal trip with Skip, she watches him sleep from the garden and sees her own reflection in the window. The image captures the novel’s uneasy loop: Fortune watches Skip, watches herself watching him, and turns an intimate moment into a scene on a screen.

The pleasure isn’t only in seeing the fantasy. It’s in observing herself as the person who sees it. That distance lets Fortune rehearse desire without having to act on it. But it also keeps her from the life she hopes television will deliver. The imagined emcee can encourage her, and the imagined audience can reward her, yet neither can close the space between performance and contact.

As Fortune’s grip on reality loosens, Buchanan’s jokes acquire a harder edge. Fortune’s isolation and sexual naïveté evoke the lonely, self-narrating figures of American film, but Maiden follows her toward a far more volatile destination. Its late turn suggests that when she can’t reach intimacy, violence may become the only form of consummation she can picture. The change is unsettling precisely because the novel has spent so long making performance seem harmless.

Artifice as a way to become a self

Buchanan doesn’t treat Fortune’s inventions as evidence that she’s empty or fake. They’re the materials she has for making a self. In an essay published the same year as the novel, Buchanan argued, “To marry our true selves, we must forgive our false ones,” adding that “nothing is more earnest, more real than falseness, nothing more human.” That idea clarifies the novel’s sympathy for a heroine who makes herself up in every sense.

First published to positive reviews, Maiden briefly attracted interest as a possible film. The rights sold, and Jane Wagner worked toward an adaptation; a proposed television special called “Wooden Nickels” never made it out of development. Hagfish’s edition gives readers another chance to encounter a book that once looked ready for a larger audience, then slipped from view.

Its return feels timely for reasons that have little to do with nostalgia. Buchanan saw how entertainment could shape private expectations, while her heroine turns every encounter into an audition and every fantasy into a show. Maiden is at its most unsettling when Fortune stops asking whether the performance will win her a life and starts mistaking the performance for the life itself.