Modern witchcraft has a history worth understanding—and it’s more complicated than the stories many practitioners first encounter. The books in this reading list approach that history from different angles: as folklore, lived practice, political conflict and imaginative fiction. Together, they offer a useful starting point for readers who want their witchcraft reading to be both curious and grounded.
I came to witchcraft after a period of upheaval, when ideas I’d kept at arm’s length as academic subjects began to feel personal. As a kitchen witch, I find magic in the work of making: turning ingredients into food, drink and ritual. But the first books I found on witchcraft left me wanting. They offered spells and folklore without much attention to where those traditions came from or how they’d been translated. I wanted a fuller account.
One place to begin is with the stories modern witchcraft tells about its own past. The so-called Burning Times—the popular claim that the witch trials targeted members of an ancient pagan religion and burned them alive—doesn’t hold up as straightforward history. Most people sentenced to death in the trials were hanged, and the idea of an underground witch religion was advanced in influential work that treated coerced confessions as reliable testimony.
Margaret Murray’s The Witch Cult in Western Europe, published in 1921, helped popularize that theory. Murray argued that accused witches belonged to a surviving pre-Christian cult, despite the use of torture in obtaining many confessions. Her ideas later shaped Gerald Gardner, who founded Wicca and described it as a remnant of an ancient goddess religion. Murray wrote the introduction to Gardner’s 1954 book, Witchcraft Today.
Gardner also drew, in part, on Aleister Crowley, whose treatment of women and use of ideas from other cultures deserve scrutiny. Crowley founded Thelema in the early 20th century, a religion centered on self-actualization. Its best-known phrase, “Do what thou wilt shall be the whole of the law,” comes from The Book of the Law. A small number of people still follow Thelema. Crowley is also credited with adding the “k” to “magick.”
That history matters to me as a writer and as the founder of the Study Coven, an independent study series for witchy women writers. When I began teaching classes on witches in literature, I wanted books that could speak to one another, making room for difficult subjects alongside questions of practice and belief. Amanda Yates Garcia’s memoir Initiated, Ariel Gore’s genre-bending We Were Witches and Pam Grossman’s blend of memoir and cultural history, Waking the Witch, all opened up conversations about power, violence, sex work and awakening.
Those conversations also shaped my writing. It took about eight years to complete my novel, Witches of the Wheel. The early drafts came quickly and intuitively, but they didn’t yet convey the force of magic I wanted the story to carry. Revision, and close questioning of the manuscript, gave the book its eventual shape. It follows Gold, a young woman who sees spirits. After her mother dies, Gold leaves home and finds work at a secret magical queer bar, where bottles refill themselves and a local coven meets. Joining the group means confronting an ancient goddess whose power threatens to destroy.
The books below aren’t a complete library of witchcraft. Think of them as a varied introduction: some recover histories, some question received accounts, and others use fiction to imagine what witchhood can mean.
History, healing and power
The Conjuring of America by Lindsey Stewart
Stewart traces the practices and knowledge of Black women conjure workers, including the herbal remedies and rituals enslaved women used to care for their communities and assist with childbirth. The book draws on mythology, research and firsthand accounts from enslaved people to map the varied influences of conjure in the United States. Its strength lies in showing how knowledge developed under oppression could endure and inform practices still used today.
Witches, Midwives, and Nurses by Barbara Ehrenreich and Deirdre English
First published by the Feminist Press in 1973, this short work examines the exclusion of women healers from medicine and the ways professional power shaped control over women’s bodies. Its argument about the connections between medical authority and the persecution of women remains pointed. The newer edition also gives readers a lens on the book’s continuing relevance in a post-Roe context.
Waking the Witch by Pam Grossman
Grossman mixes personal experience with an engaging account of witchcraft in popular culture, fairy tales and horror. The result ranges across subjects including Victoria Woodhull, the Spiritualists who sought communication with the dead and the cultural influence of The Wizard of Oz. It’s a welcoming guide for readers who want historical context alongside an exploration of how witches appear in the stories a culture tells about itself.
Witches, Sluts, Feminists by Kristen J Sollee
Sollee studies the witch as a figure in art, media, literature, pop culture and politics, following the ways accusations of witchiness have been used to police women—and how women have turned that figure into a source of resistance. Research and interviews take the book into sexuality, sex work, queerness, pornography, pleasure and reproductive rights. It’s a lively account of how the witch’s cultural meaning keeps shifting alongside debates about women’s autonomy.
Memoir and the search for a practice
Initiated by Amanda Yates Garcia
Garcia recounts a searching path through poverty, sex work, travel, love and magic, charting her development into the Oracle of LA. This is a memoir that takes the spiritual seriously while staying close to the conditions of ordinary life. One line captures its central sensibility: “Witches use magic to compost suffering into something nourishing, something that brings the world around us to life.”
We Were Witches by Ariel Gore
Gore writes about a young mother trying to get an education, establish herself as a writer, manage her mental health and care for her daughter while making ends meet. The book’s shifting form is part of its argument: identity and story resist neat boundaries. Its treatment of shame is especially incisive, as in the observation, “Maybe what shame needs to stay alive is the consent of the shamed.” Readers looking for a memoir that takes both material hardship and imagination seriously will find plenty here.
Witches of America by Alex Mar
Mar began studying the occult while making a documentary and approached paganism and witchcraft as a skeptic. Her reporting takes her into rituals and communities, including an apprenticeship, while leaving the reader to watch her relationship with belief develop. The book also prompted debate over how its subjects were presented and what information Mar chose to reveal. That tension is worth keeping in mind; the memoir may especially appeal to readers who are curious about witchcraft but haven’t settled what they believe.
Witches in fiction
Bunny by Mona Awad
Samantha Mackey feels stranded in an elite MFA program, where her wealthy classmates form an insular clique and call one another “Bunny.” When they invite her in, she’s tempted by their glittering world, even as the choice risks her friendship with Ava. Awad turns loneliness, social belonging and artistic ambition into strange, sharp material for a novel of witchcraft unlike the familiar kind. There’s also a sequel.
The Manningtree Witches by AK Blakemore
Set amid civil war, hunger and fear, Blakemore’s novel follows Rebecca and her hard-drinking mother as a witch hunter, Matthew Hopkins, turns suspicion toward them. The historical figure’s presence gives the story an unsettling anchor: a community under pressure looks for someone to blame, and unattached women make easy targets. Blakemore’s background as a poet is evident in the novel’s language, which brings precision to a story about accusation and survival.
Rootwork by Tracy Cross
The first book in Cross’s The Conjure Series, this historical novel opens in 1889, when three young sisters spend the summer with their Aunt Teddy in Louisiana. Teddy teaches them hoodoo and offers hard-earned lessons about life. The girls enjoy their new freedom until tragedy changes the course of their summer. Cross brings historical fiction, folklore and horror together in a story about love, revenge and the knowledge passed between generations.
She Would Be King by Wayétu Moore
Moore brings together three people with extraordinary powers: June, who has superhuman strength and is bulletproof; Norman, who can disappear under certain conditions; and Gbessa, a cursed woman called a witch who cannot die. Their paths lead from Virginia and Jamaica to Monrovia, where the story reaches the founding of Liberia. The novel asks what freedom can mean in a racist, Christianized world, while making the witch both powerful and an outcast.
Lolly Willowes by Sylvia Townsend Warner
Warner’s novel follows a middle-aged aunt who leaves her demanding London family and settles in a remote village, where she answers the devil’s call. The premise turns the expected dangers of a pact on their head: the wider world, rather than witchcraft, is the source of much of the trouble. Playful and satirical, Lolly Willowes uses its witch protagonist to question the roles families assign to women.
These books make a strong reading course because they don’t agree on what a witch is or where witchcraft begins. Some revisit the histories that shaped modern practice; others turn to memoir and fiction to test what power, belonging and belief feel like from the inside. Read together, they leave room for a more informed practice—and for the questions that make it personal.