When a work of art asks to be touched
At SFMOMA, a blue photograph made with seawater prompted a question the museum’s rules couldn’t settle: what do we lose when protecting art means keeping people at a distance? The work was Meghan Riepenhoff’s Littoral Drift Nearshore #209, a grid of cyanotype squares marked with white streaks and swirls. Riepenhoff had thrown water and silt from Washington’s Fletcher Bay across photosensitive paper. The result looked to DS Waldman like a wave caught in the act of breaking. Waldman had a long-term press pass while working on a first book of poems and art criticism, and brought his mother to see the museum’s cameraless photography gallery. She was an old-process photographer who loved the ocean but lived in landlocked Kentucky. After studying the work from a distance, she walked up, lifted one blue square from the wall, and turned it to inspect the back. A nearby attendant shouted at her, then warned that she could be asked to leave if she touched the art again. Outside the gallery, Waldman’s mother was embarrassed and bewildered. “I don’t know what got into me,” she said. She told him she’d felt like a child, giving in to the impulse to reach out. For the rest of their visit, she kept behind the floor tape and held her hands behind her back. Waldman was upset by the public scolding, though he doesn’t blame the attendant for enforcing the rules. Art needs protection if it is to remain available to future visitors. But the encounter left him weighing that duty against the way museums regulate the experience of looking: ropes, tape, glass, guards and cameras can make a gallery feel less like an invitation than a monitored space.Who gets to be close to art?
The barriers begin before visitors enter the gallery. Major museums often sit in expensive cities, and admission can put them out of reach for many people. Even those who can afford a ticket may find the experience formal and uneasy. A former teacher of Waldman’s, herself a poet and art lover, said museums made her feel “constipated.” Waldman has grown used to that formality, and can’t readily picture how museums might protect valuable works while making the encounter feel less rigid. The tension, he suggests, runs deeper than museum etiquette. It reflects the way art is treated as property, with access shaped by money and market value. He recalls a scene in Garth Greenwell’s novel Cleanness. An American narrator living in Bulgaria watches a former student set a carton of orange juice on an ancient marble pillar in a public square. The narrator reacts with alarm; the student jokes that the American is out of place, since “we have stuff like this everywhere.” In that scene, antiquities are part of the shared city, available to sit on or use as a table. Waldman reads the student’s “American” as a stand-in for “capitalist.” The pillar seems to have escaped the market’s grip. By contrast, celebrated art and archaeology—from Riepenhoff’s cyanotypes to objects in the Met’s Egyptian galleries—sit behind what he calls the glass plate of money, markets and valuation.Preservation has a price
A private visit to the Met’s painting conservation department gave Waldman a closer look at that price. As a college senior, he toured the studios with his art history thesis cohort. He had expected a sterile laboratory; instead, he found a bright, warm workspace with tall windows, wooden tables, stools and easels. Their guide, Sarah, showed them a Renaissance fresco and explained how she removed discolored varnish and old overpainting, retouched losses and “ingilded” abrasions. She spoke with evident wonder about the work—and also about its financial stakes. A small blemish, she warned, could affect a painting’s valuation if it were neglected or treated poorly. She also recalled a nineteenth-century American portrait being dropped, its original frame breaking. “I don’t know what that did to its value,” she said, “but it was a horror story.” The visit left Waldman’s awe mixed with disillusionment. Conservation is skilled, careful work, but the language of valuation shadows it. A mark on a painting matters both as damage to an object and as a potential loss in price. That memory took him back to a sculpture on his college campus by Patrick Dougherty, known for outdoor works made from woven sticks. Called So Inclined, it formed tall, hollow structures with paths running through them. Visitors could walk inside and touch the walls, their hands meeting the same material the artist had handled. The piece could have been wrecked by a car or a chainsaw. It wasn’t. Waldman saw beauty in the shared, unspoken decision to leave it unharmed while allowing time to wear it down. The community preserved the work—and accepted that it would eventually disappear.Art made to disappear
Waldman’s professor later pointed him toward Gordon Matta-Clark, the artist behind the idea of “Anarchitecture”: art and architecture released, as far as possible, from systems of authority and the high art market. Before his death at 35 in 1978, Matta-Clark made about 50 works, often by altering buildings already headed for demolition. In 1974, he cut a New Jersey house in half, exposing its interior like a cross-section in a children’s picture book. He also cut a large hole through an art gallery floor and built a spiral staircase into the earth below. At Manhattan’s Pier 52 in 1975, he made broad cuts in the floors and walls, opening views—and routes—toward the Hudson River. Light entered through the wall openings in slanted shafts visitors could walk through. Matta-Clark’s projects were generally open to the public without tickets or instructions. For the Pier 52 work, he had no permit; people slipped through a chain-link fence to see it. The city issued a warrant for his arrest, and he briefly left the country. None of the works remain. They were demolished, destroyed or, in the gallery’s case, filled in. Photographs and eyewitness accounts are all that survive. That disappearance may have suited Matta-Clark’s intent. Yet photographs of the works later entered the market, and Waldman says he couldn’t find auction data without paying more than $1,000 for an annual subscription to an appraiser database. He can imagine a different history: New York preserves Pier 52, restores it and charges $30 for admission. Or Dougherty’s stick sculpture is treated with chemicals and moved to MoMA for decades of display. Either might keep the work visible, but preservation would also turn an impermanent public encounter into something climate-controlled and precious. The artist might not be the person who benefits most, and the viewer could lose the chance to meet the work on its own terms.The force of a hand
Waldman wonders whether contact with the public really has to lower a work’s value. If a painting’s price depends on remaining untouched, then touch has an unusual power: it could alter the market’s judgment without substantially altering the painting itself. He imagines people in major museums crossing the barriers together and placing their hands on the Rembrandts, Basquiats, Dalís and Monet’s Water Lilies. In his thought experiment, the paintings remain mostly intact, with only the oils from people’s hands left behind, while their values plunge. That imagined gesture has real, more destructive counterparts. In early 2025, members of Last Generation Canada threw pink paint across Picasso’s L’hétaire. The UK group Just Stop Oil has staged similar attacks on works by van Gogh and Degas. In August 2024, Last Generation Austria poured black oil over Klimt’s Death and Life; one protester glued a hand to the frame. The painting itself was protected by glass. Waldman rejects deliberately damaging another person’s art. Still, he sees a point in the choice of targets: canonical works carry cultural and financial weight, and touch can challenge the systems that guard that value. It can also deepen a viewer’s experience. He remembers being 22 and running his hands along the interior walls of Dougherty’s installation—a physical connection across time between the artist’s hands and his own.Mobiles made for motion
Alexander Calder offers another way to think about touch and movement. Before visiting SFMOMA, Waldman had seen Calder’s mobiles only in lecture slides. The museum’s exhibition “Dissonant Harmony,” on view when he wrote, placed the mobiles in a sunlit gallery alongside other works, including small model villages with motorized trains. The mobiles hang at different heights. Visitors can walk all the way around the three largest, seeing their varied wires, shapes and colored metal pieces from every angle. Calder described the principle in a quotation on the gallery wall: “Disparity in form, color, size, weight, motion, is what makes a composition.” Waldman could see that disparity in the shifting lengths of wire and the differently colored spades. He could also sense that the works were made to move, perhaps in the open air. Calder once gave a large mobile to Piet Mondrian in exchange for workspace on Mondrian’s property in southern France. Mondrian hung it outside, where it caught the coastal breeze from the Gulf of Lion.When the Mobiles Move
The Calder mobiles look made for motion, yet museums usually ask visitors to admire them while they hang still. SFMOMA once addressed that tension with “Calder in Motion,” a ticketed event where specially trained staff set the works turning. I went both days on a press pass. The gallery was packed, nearly claustrophobic, as a staff member used a tool he called his “Calder push stick”—something like an oversized Q-tip—to nudge the wire near the dangling spades. He moved with care, sending each mobile into a slow whirl. The gesture brought to mind pushing a canoe from shore. Music may have been playing overhead; children watched from their parents’ shoulders.
It was pleasant, but a little strange. The crowd, the ceremony and the expensive tickets sat uneasily beside the mobiles’ ordinary, wind-chime quality. I’d seen them move before, without an event built around the act.
A child, a spade, a gust
That earlier encounter came about a year and a half before, on a Tuesday morning after the incident in which my mother touched a cyanotype. I reached SFMOMA at opening and had half an hour to wander while other visitors checked their coats and bags and bought tickets. I spent time with an early Braque and the large Rivera mural, then found myself alone in the Calder gallery, circling the mobiles and taking them in from near and far.
A noise in the corridor broke the quiet. A boy, perhaps five or six, had slipped away from his mother. I saw—or imagined I saw—the moment coming before he entered the room. Rainboots clicked across the floor as he ran toward a mobile; his mother followed with their jackets and a disposable camera. She called his name, Julian, then called again as she hurried after him.
She reached him as he reached the sculpture, arm drawn back, hand open. In that instant, the mobile seemed to gather other kinds of movement I remembered: its irregular turns among the trees between Mondrián’s home and the sea; branches bobbing in wind; my hand, ten years earlier, tracing the rugged weave of the Dougherty outside the art building; the Hudson wrinkling through the cut slats of Pier 52.
Memory may have edited the scene. I think Julian’s mother was close enough to stop him, and I wondered where the guard was. But she let him slap the small red spade near the floor. A breeze caught the mobile and set it turning, briefly, in the late-morning San Francisco light. Then she took his hand, and they left.
That small, unceremonious touch made the mobiles’ movement feel less like a museum performance and more like what it is: a response to the world around them. The ticketed event could make that motion visible, but it also wrapped a simple encounter in money and formality. Julian’s gust of contact lasted only a moment. It stayed with me longer.
The post The Power of Touch in High Art appeared first on Electric Literature.