Minimalist Mules Get a Little Competition
Minimalist mules have become a familiar red-carpet choice, from Paris Texas’ Lidia style to the broader crop of pared-back designs. Their appeal is easy to read: a clean toe strap and slim heel can sit quietly beneath a dress, while still looking polished in photographs. Denée Benton and Dua Lipa suggest there’s room for a dressier counterpoint: black satin mules with conspicuous jewelry details. The shift is small, but useful. A single embellished accent can turn a basic slip-on into an evening shoe without changing the silhouette that made mules popular.
Benton wore Paul Andrew’s black satin Glitter Ball mules to the New York premiere of HBO’s “The Gilded Age” season four on Monday. The peep-toe pair has a broad vamp, a narrow front cutout and a diamanté-covered crystal ball set above the opening. Its 3.75-inch stiletto gives the shoe a sharper profile; the crystal detail does the work of making it feel suited to a night out. The proportions matter: the broad upper gives the ornament room to register, while the heel keeps the shoe from reading as a flat or casual slip-on.
The shoes also echoed Benton’s strapless black-and-silver gown, which carried a braided column of crystal and beadwork down the front. That coordination makes the mules feel considered rather than merely sparkly. It’s a useful styling distinction: an embellished shoe can either compete with an outfit or pick up a detail that’s already there. Here, the matching materials connect the accessories and dress, so the shoes read as part of the look rather than a separate bid for attention.
Lipa took a related approach at the Metropolitan Opera’s Oct. 19 opening gala for “Lincoln in the Bardo” in New York. She paired a Ferragamo dress with the black satin stilettos shown alongside it at Ferragamo’s spring 2027 show during Milan Fashion Week in September. The runway pairing gives the look a direct link to the collection, while the shoe’s dark color and jewelry detail make the styling legible beyond the show context. That’s a familiar path for runway footwear: a striking accessory can gain a second life when a celebrity wears it with an occasion look.
Lipa’s pair has a pointed toe and a V-shaped vamp topped with a gold-tone jewelry ornament. Black stones, gold-finished metal and pavé crystal detailing give it depth, while a curved heel of about four inches adds a sculptural finish. The precise stone materials aren’t clear, but the effect is: the embellishment carries the visual weight without changing the shoe’s clean silhouette. That balance is the appeal. The shoe makes a statement at close range and in a full-length look, yet its outline remains familiar.
Maximalist mules make their case
Dakota Johnson’s Valentino mules capture the shift underway in celebrity footwear: after a year dominated by pared-back, single-strap styles, decoration is back in the spotlight. She wore the black Coeur Vipère Kidskin Slide Sandal at the Time 100 Gala at Jazz at Lincoln Center in New York on April 23, 2026. WWD’s report on Johnson’s look identifies the shoe as the Valentino Garavani 105mm Strass Snake Leather Mule Heel. The specific model name signals the design’s priorities: this is a high-heel mule built around a decorative motif, not an attempt to disappear beneath the hemline.
The design makes its point through detail: a heart-shaped cutout creates a peep-toe effect, while a strass snake sits across the wide front strap. Smooth black leather, a red-and-gold sole, and a 105mm (4.25-inch) stiletto complete the slip-on mule. The pair costs $1,250 on Valentino’s website. That price places it firmly in the designer category, where ornament and brand identity are part of what’s being sold alongside the basic function of a shoe. The styling idea, though, is more transferable: one distinct motif can give a familiar shape a different attitude.
Kirsten Dunst wore the same style to Valentino’s spring 2026 show in Paris in January. That celebrity visibility matters because it gives the ornate shoe a clear counterpoint to the minimalist mule, whose slim heel and simple toe strap became a red-carpet and street-style staple. Repetition across different public settings can make a design feel less like a one-off styling choice and more like a trend with some momentum. Still, appearances alone don’t show how widely shoppers will adopt it.
What the return of decoration signals
The bigger signal is the timing. Crystal-embellished shoes have featured prominently in fall 2026 and spring 2027 collections, with runway debuts and celebrity appearances helping push the trend along. WWD’s coverage of embellished footwear tracks that broader turn. The shift looks real, though it’s not yet clear whether maximalist mules will have the staying power of their minimalist predecessors. A few high-profile looks can establish a direction, but a lasting change depends on whether the style works outside formal events and fashion week.
Here’s the thing: decoration doesn’t have to mean a return to complicated footwear. These examples keep the recognizable mule shape and concentrate the visual interest at the vamp, heel or toe opening. That gives designers room to change the mood of a shoe without asking wearers to learn a new silhouette. And this is the part most people overlook: a familiar shape can make a bold detail easier to wear, since the rest of the shoe already feels known.
This is more significant than it looks. If you’re working in this space, the contrast suggests that shoppers and stylists may be ready for more personality in a category that has leaned on restraint. The test will be whether the ornament feels useful beyond a red carpet: whether it can complement different outfits, and whether it adds enough to justify choosing it over a simpler pair. For now, the evidence is strongest in celebrity styling and runway collections, so the broader appeal remains an open question. A small detail, with a lot riding on it.
For a look at the style they’re challenging, see WWD’s gallery of celebrities wearing minimalist mules.