DC Studios’ early slate suggests James Gunn and Peter Safran are building a franchise around filmmaker choice, not a tightly plotted release schedule. That could give the company more distinctive films and shows than the familiar superhero formula. It also leaves the strategy exposed to a blunt test: each project still has to work on its own.
Four years after Warner Bros. named Gunn and Safran co-CEOs, there’s enough released work to assess the direction, even though the larger plan remains in its first phase. The pair inherited an unusually deep roster and a troubled film brand. Their results so far include three theatrical films, two live-action series and animated projects. The mix makes the intent visible. The uneven reception shows how difficult that intent will be to sustain.
Superman set the tone, but not the full test
Gunn began the new DC film chapter with its most recognizable hero. His “Superman” movie bypassed the familiar origin story, introducing Clark Kent and Superman after both identities were already established. That choice let the film get straight to character and conflict, while its color, humor and emotional warmth marked a clear departure from the grim tone associated with many DC films of the 2010s.
The result was an accessible blockbuster that grossed more than $600 million worldwide. It demonstrated Gunn’s ability to make a crowd pleasing comic book film, something few doubted after his earlier work. But the movie offered limited evidence about a different part of his job: guiding projects made by other directors. That distinction matters. Running a studio means trusting other voices and finding ways to keep their work compelling without making every film feel like an extension of one filmmaker’s style.
“Supergirl,” directed by Craig Gillespie, put that question under pressure. Milly Alcock’s character first appeared briefly in “Superman”; the solo film then sent her through a space western built around a series of “Mad Max”-like planets. The change in setting and tone was a substantial departure from Gunn’s Earthbound Superman story, and the film’s mythology and visual effects drew mixed responses. It earned $100 million worldwide against a reported budget nearly twice as high.
Reports of creative disagreements between Gunn, Safran and Gillespie added to the concern. Two versions of the film were reportedly screened against each other months before release. That account doesn’t settle what went wrong, but it makes “Supergirl” a pointed early test of how DC Studios handles conflicting creative instincts. A single commercial disappointment wouldn’t define a slate. Yet with only three theatrical releases in the sample, the film accounts for a meaningful share of the results.
“Clayface” offers a different kind of test. James Watkins’ body horror story centers on an actor who sacrifices everything to regain his appearance, taking a Batman villain with limited mainstream recognition into gory, deliberately unsettling territory. The film didn’t need to appeal to every superhero audience member to justify its place. At $44 million, its budget left room for a narrower audience and a more specific directorial vision. That’s a useful counterweight to expensive franchise tentpoles, provided audiences can find and embrace the film.
Television gives other creators more room
Gunn’s television work offers a clearer example of what a looser DC slate can accomplish. “Peacemaker,” which premiered before he and Safran took over, carried John Cena’s character from Gunn’s “Suicide Squad” into a raunchy action comedy. HBO Max gave the series space for profanity and nudity that would be difficult to fit into a broad theatrical release. Its reception showed how a premium series could extend DC’s range while retaining the sensibility of a filmmaker who already knew the material.
The animated “Creature Commandos”, the first official project after the leadership change, debuted in December 2024 with a six episode first season. Its focus on oddballs forming a found family fits Gunn’s recurring interests, but its larger significance may be structural: the voice actors were cast with the intention that they could reprise their roles in live action. Gunn has said he plans to use that approach for future animated projects, creating one route for characters to move between formats.
“Peacemaker” later returned for a well received second season, but “Lanterns” became the most revealing demonstration of the studio’s television ambitions. Created by Chris Mundy, Damon Lindelof and Tom King, the series recasts the Green Lantern premise as a middle American murder investigation. Its older, rigid lead and younger partner draw on familiar police drama dynamics, while the season long mystery gives the show its own shape. The reviews were strong, but the larger point is the format: a distinct creative team can make a series that sits within DC’s shared story without treating every episode as a bridge to the next film.
That arrangement could give DC a useful identity. The franchise can support superhero spectacle, horror and crime drama under one banner, leaving room for filmmakers to work in different registers. The challenge is to make those projects feel connected enough to build recognition, while preserving the independence that gives them their appeal.
Batman remains the franchise’s structural gap
The biggest complication may be a character Gunn and Safran did not place in their new universe. Matt Reeves’ “The Batman” opened before they took charge, and Warner Bros. chose to continue Robert Pattinson’s version outside the main DC storyline. A sequel is in production, with Steven Soderbergh helping complete principal photography. HBO projects including “The Penguin” and the announced “Poison Ivy” series also extend that separate corner of Gotham.
Gunn and Safran support those projects and have some involvement, but they don’t control them as pieces of the central DC narrative. That division isn’t inherently confusing: comic books have long allowed different creative teams to tell separate versions of stories about the same characters. Still, Batman is one of the company’s most valuable figures, and keeping him outside the main continuity limits which characters can anchor the new universe’s biggest crossovers.
A separate DCU Batman appears likely, especially with Batman’s villains already entering the picture in “Clayface.” Gunn and Safran previously chose Andy Muschietti to direct “The Brave and the Bold,” but as of 2025 the project remained in development, with no announced cast or release date. The delay leaves a gap in the franchise’s central cast and raises a practical question: how will audiences distinguish this Batman from Pattinson’s when both versions appear in active projects?
The separation creates a challenge for future team films. A new Justice League or a Batman and Superman pairing would ordinarily depend on the Dark Knight’s presence. If the new DCU introduces its own version, viewers may compare him with Pattinson’s, whose series already has an established identity. Gunn and Safran inherited this arrangement, but they’ll still need to make it legible if the shared universe is to expand around its most familiar heroes.
A script first model needs consistent execution
DC Studios’ approach looks deliberately different from Marvel’s interconnected release model. Gunn has described a process in which films are greenlit on the strength of their scripts, rather than their role in filling out a continuity map. The choice of “Clayface” makes that claim concrete: an origin story for a less familiar Batman villain is an unusual early franchise release, but Mike Flanagan’s script stood out among the projects under consideration.
That priority could benefit both audiences and filmmakers. Viewers who care more about a film’s individual story than its place in a sequence may get a more varied slate. Directors and writers can pitch projects shaped by their interests instead of serving primarily as links between installments. The costs are clear, too. A script first slate may produce looser continuity, and projects announced during development may never reach production. James Mangold’s “Swamp Thing” and Luca Guadagnino’s “Sgt. Rock” are among the projects that fell away.
Gunn has also said no DC Studios film will receive a release date until the script is ready. It’s a sound principle, but a good development rule can’t guarantee a good finished film. “Supergirl” makes that gap hard to ignore: the mixed reception and weak box office leave a basic question about how the project changed between its script and its release.
My read is that DC’s strategy has a coherent creative argument and an unsettled business case. “Superman” shows that Gunn can deliver a major hit in his own voice; “Lanterns” shows how other creators can build distinctive work inside the same franchise; and “Clayface” suggests that smaller budgets can make unusual ideas more feasible. “Supergirl” shows that those principles still have to survive production and find an audience.
The next stage will depend on whether DC can repeat that variety while strengthening its central cast and keeping each project clear on its own terms. Gunn’s planned “Superman” follow-up is dated for July 2027, while the new Batman remains without a release date. Those projects will show whether this filmmaker led model can deliver both individual stories with character and a shared universe people want to follow.