This week’s strongest-reviewed books span crime fiction, personal journalism, comics and cultural criticism. Walter Mosley’s latest King Oliver mystery leads the fiction list, while nonfiction standouts revisit Sherlock Holmes’s origins, life on death row and the making of Larry David’s television career. The range is broad, but several books share an interest in how people build identities: through family ties, public reputations, faith or the stories told about them.
Fiction: crime, culture and close bonds
1. Hanging & Burning by Walter Mosley (Little, Brown and Company) — 5 rave reviews. The fourth King Oliver novel earns praise for its sharp dialogue, colorful characters and jazz-inflected atmosphere. Booklist reviewer Donna Seaman highlights Mosley’s wit and his command of the book’s mix of family, crime and high-stakes confrontations. That combination gives the mystery room to work on more than one level: the investigation supplies momentum, while relationships and social pressures shape what the characters stand to lose. Five rave reviews make it the clear critical leader in this week’s fiction group.
2. Doppelgänger by Sam Riviere (Catapult) — 2 rave, 2 positive reviews. Riviere takes aim at the machinery of “Culture” while making broader observations about society. Writing in The Financial Times, Matthew Janney says the book avoids reproducing the very tendencies it critiques, emerging as a singular work. That tension matters: criticism of a cultural system can easily borrow its habits, including the urge to turn every subject into a performance. Janney’s assessment suggests Riviere is alert to that trap, even as the book takes on a wide target.
3. Paradise Burns by Pol Guasch (FSG Originals) — 2 rave, 1 positive review. The novel centers on the enduring friendship between Líton and Rita. Kirkus praises the tenderness of their bond and calls the book a perceptive portrait of friendship. A relationship at the center of a novel can be a demanding subject: it has to feel intimate without becoming static, and its changes need to carry the story. The review’s emphasis on tenderness points to a book whose force comes from attention to the connection itself. Read an excerpt from Paradise Burns.
4. Queen of Lombard Street by Lisa Kleypas (Avon Books) — 1 rave, 2 positive reviews. This historical novel pairs romance with economics. Kirkus describes it as clever, well-researched and a delight. That pairing gives the book a way to connect private relationships with the systems that shape money and status; the historical setting can supply more than period detail if those forces affect the characters’ choices. The reviews suggest Kleypas makes that blend entertaining as well as considered.
5. The Turning of Sally-Mae by Nuzo Onoh (Titan Books) — 1 positive, 2 mixed reviews. Library Journal recommends the book to readers of V. Castro’s The Queen of the Cicadas and LaTanya McQueen’s When the Reckoning Comes. That comparison gives prospective readers a useful sense of its company, though it doesn’t settle how the novel will land for someone new to Onoh’s work. The mixed reviews point to a more divided response than the books above it, making this the least clear-cut selection in the fiction group.
Nonfiction: hidden histories and personal accounts
1. Sleuth-Hound: The Case of the Real Sherlock Holmes by Lindsey Fitzharris (Farrar, Straus and Giroux) — 2 rave, 4 positive reviews. Fitzharris brings Dr. Joseph Bell back into the story of Sherlock Holmes, arguing for Bell’s place as an inspiration and model for Arthur Conan Doyle’s detective. The premise shifts attention from the fictional investigator to the real person whose methods may have helped shape him. That kind of historical recovery can sharpen a reader’s understanding of a famous character, while also asking how much credit belongs to influence and how much to an author’s invention. The reviews lean positive, though the list records more positive than rave notices.
2. Redemption: Faith, Justice, and Sisterhood on Death Row by Lawrence Wright (Knopf) — 3 rave, 1 positive, 1 mixed review. Wright’s reported portraits of prisoners and nuns examine guilt, justice and the possibility of change. The Boston Globe calls the book a moving, thoughtful work of journalism, and notes that its individual profiles reward reading in short stretches. That structure fits reporting built around distinct lives: readers can pause between accounts without losing the shape of the subject. The mixed review also signals that the book’s approach may not persuade everyone, a useful reminder that intimate portraits and questions of justice can invite complicated responses.
3. I Can’t Stop Thinking about Horses and Sex by Lisa Hanawalt (Drawn and Quarterly) — 3 rave, 1 positive review. Hanawalt uses jokes and vivid animal drawings to explore personal subjects with unusual precision. The New York Times Book Review praises the book’s directness and its willingness to show parts of the artist she might otherwise conceal. Humor can make difficult or awkward subjects easier to approach, but it also gives an artist room to control how much she reveals and on what terms. Here, the reviews point to a voice that uses both drawing and candor as part of the argument. Funny, and sharply self-aware.
4. Our Arab: On Longing, Belonging, and Hope by Zaina Arafat (Little, Brown and Company) — 2 rave, 1 positive review. Publishers Weekly describes Arafat’s book as a powerful examination of the pain experienced by Palestinians in exile. Its focus on longing and belonging places personal experience alongside the dislocation of exile, giving the book both an intimate and a broader frame. The review’s description points to a work concerned with the emotional cost of separation, rather than treating exile as an abstract condition. For readers, that emphasis may make the account especially affecting.
5. Emperor of Nothing: The Making of Larry David by Blake J. Harris (Dey Street Books) — 3 positive, 1 mixed review. Harris traces the creation and development of Larry David’s two best-known television comedies. The Wall Street Journal finds the account lively and intimate, while observing that it leans toward admiration and gives little attention to David’s romantic life. That reservation goes to a central problem for biographies of prominent creative figures: access and narrative energy can come at the expense of distance. Harris’s account appears engaging, though readers looking for a more skeptical portrait may find its emphasis narrow.
What the week’s reviews suggest
Taken together, the week’s picks reward readers drawn to distinct voices and close observation: from Mosley’s jazz-tempered crime fiction to Wright’s deeply reported profiles and Hanawalt’s candid illustrated essays. They also show how much a book’s subject can shape the form it takes, whether a novel follows a friendship, a journalist builds a story from individual lives or an artist turns personal material into comics. Here’s the thing: review counts can point readers toward books attracting broad approval, but they can’t tell you which voice or subject will hold your attention.
This is more significant than it looks: across fiction and nonfiction, several of these books turn on the gap between a person and the story others tell about them. If you’re working in publishing, criticism or cultural reporting, that shared concern is a useful thread through an otherwise varied list (and this is the part most people overlook). The books approach it from different angles, and the reviews offer a starting point for choosing among them. That said, the strongest recommendation here may be the simplest one: follow the subjects that make you curious, then see how each writer handles the evidence, the relationships and the limits of what can be known.