Aphantasia: A Floor Plan by Josepha Natzke

Front Stairwell

The bed frame catches at the last turn of the stairs. We’re near the top, trying to maneuver its white beam through a stairwell the previous owners painted dark mauve. The frame’s sharp edge scrapes the soft pink wall and exposes chalky plaster. This is our fourth move as a married couple. I warn you before we start, because we always fight when we move furniture. I make a plan; you pick things up. I worry; you carry. We argue over angles and sweat through the job. I blame you for the gouge. Above us, a cloudy window has a frame the color of a bruise. A painting left by the former owners, Maximeno and Ramona, shows a man and woman dancing beside a clock. Its time is impossible to read. The picture feels like a reminder, though I can’t say what it’s reminding us of.

Lot Characteristics and Size

We bought this place because it was one of the few houses we could afford in this northwest Chicago neighborhood, and because we knew how to repair it. We’ve learned to rewire outlets, frame walls, and patch drywall. Fixing things is part of how we live together. So is living in houses that seem to be coming apart. The lot is 25 feet wide and 125 feet long, on a narrow city street mostly lined with parked cars and litter. Built in 1895, the house looks small beside its neighbors. Its second-floor balcony is unlike any we’d seen in the city: a mildewed porch with a white railing, sagging in the middle and probably not up to code. On closing day, we carry two camp chairs out there and sit in the sun with a bottle of lukewarm prosecco.

Bathroom

I start cleaning from the bathroom ceiling and work downward: walls, mirrors, tile, floor. The house’s former occupants have left behind brown grease rings overhead, hair and softened toenails in the shower drain, a soap bottle and an industrial roll of single-ply toilet paper under the sink. The shower’s scummy corners make me gag. Still, I don’t mind the work. Soap drips and gray hairs are ordinary traces of a body. A bathroom is where people leave them behind. It’s gross, and intimate. Maximeno and Ramona owned the house for 30 years, and their decorating choices make it feel like a funhouse where nothing quite is what it claims to be. The towel rack is a curtain rod with spiny finials. Clear tape seals the gaps between windows and their frames. What look like hooks on the back of the door turn out to be nails buried under drippy layers of paint.

Living Room

Your father sends scans of old family photographs, sometimes in sudden bursts that suggest a nostalgia he rarely shows in person. One picture shows you with your younger sister Cornelia on a back deck—or perhaps a restaurant patio. Your curls are swollen with humidity, and your arm rests around her shoulder. You look like a happy older brother. “Where was this taken?” I ask. You study the picture, then shrug. “No clue.” In another, you’re perhaps 16, sitting outside and almost entirely covered in red mud dried by the Alabama sun. I laugh from the couch. “What the hell were you doing?” You don’t remember the patio, the mud, or the other pictures your father sends. You’ve never been able to recall specific childhood memories. Now, in your early 30s, you also lose track of things many people retain: friends’ last names, birthdays, bars we’ve been to before. We’ve wondered whether that comes from your parents’ divorce when you were 10, or from the years you spent being ferried between them across state lines. Maybe the memory loss is tied to trauma, perhaps even an assault your mind buried. We don’t know. I can call up scenes from my own childhood: the blackberry patch beside my childhood home, the clutter in my bedroom. Memory lays out a path for me to follow. Yours doesn’t work that way. You look at these photographs as if you’re encountering their details for the first time. I can easily picture the blackberry patch by my childhood home and the cluttered corners of my bedroom. The living room is painted pink by Maximeno and Ramona: bright as Pepto-Bismol, lacquered lip gloss, watermelon candy. It’s so saturated that I imagine the room leaves a green afterimage in our eyes when we step away. In middle school, a teacher had us stare at a red apple, then look at a white wall until the apple’s green silhouette appeared. “Do you remember?” I ask you. You don’t. You don’t remember that lesson, or hearing about it elsewhere. Maybe no one ever taught you. Your father sometimes sends the pictures in a group text with Cornelia. Others arrive in emails addressed only to you, with no subject line. Once or twice, he sends them just to me. Each photo brings back a younger you, smiling wide—a cheerful messenger from a past you can’t retrieve.

Kitchen (Eat-in)

We know we’ll eventually have to tear much of the house apart to restore it. We shouldn’t get attached to the bright walls and strange finishes. This dreamsicle palace is temporary. Still, its oddness gets under our skin. The kitchen is painted in mustard, marigold, and ochre. A stencil behind the oven imitates brick; white stripes run floor to ceiling beside the wall heater. The handmade cabinets seem to have glass fronts, until you tap them. The dull click gives them away: plexiglass. The house is a colorful facade, and every closer look turns up another surprise. On move-in day, the sink won’t run. We panic that the city has shut off our water, then go outside to the strip of grass between the sidewalk and street. We pry up the plastic cover over the shutoff valve and try several tools. It’s illegal, and pointless: the city uses a special wrench with a proprietary number of angles to stop people from turning the valve. Back inside, I unscrew the faucet nozzle, remove the filter, and detach the pull-down handle. The tube is packed with tiny, smooth rocks. I empty them, put the faucet back together, and the water runs. The cupboard above the oven is marked with pencil phone numbers. More numbers, printed on paper, are taped inside the cabinet walls. They overlap like faint cave drawings: some have surnames, others are just digits. I picture someone holding a phone to one ear, cabinet door open, searching for a number as the line rings. I put flour on the top shelf. The bag releases a white puff, but it won’t sit flat. Beneath it, my fingers find something small and hard: a single chalk-white human molar.

Office (or Bedroom)

Our bedroom is lilac. You set up a desk there and rarely use it. I edit reports remotely while you travel for weeks at a time to Phoenix, Columbus, Richmond, and Denver. We hardly speak on the phone when you’re away. That arrangement came after dozens of arguments: I wanted more calls, and you resented forgetting to call and being blamed afterward. My unanswered texts accumulate into a monologue. By the time we connect, I’m too angry to talk—which was the point, in a way. You’ve said that you struggle to remember. The minutes pass, and you forget to call. In 2019, a month into dating, we sat behind a resale shop with takeout leftovers cooling beside us. You told me, awkwardly, that you didn’t often miss people. “I want to miss them,” you said, “but I can’t remember their faces.” You watched me closely for a reaction. I had none to give. New love gave me enough grace to accept your forgetfulness as part of you. A few months later, we spent the holidays separately with our families and exchanged flight confirmations. My return flight landed a day before yours. At O’Hare, I made my way through the crowded corridors, dreading my empty apartment and wishing you might somehow be waiting. Then an arm came over my shoulder. You were grinning at me. You’d changed your flight to surprise me. “I missed you,” you said, eyes filling with tears. For you, it seemed less like a familiar feeling than a discovery. Over time, our arguments have produced a fragile routine: you try to remember that consistency matters to me, and I try to forgive you when you forget. I’m learning to trust that you don’t mean to ignore my calls. I tell myself your mind is elsewhere, racing along whatever track is in front of you, in another city. I need to believe that.

Dining Room

At the house’s center, the dining room connects to the living room and kitchen through two arched openings. Its dark red walls seem translucent. The room feels like a beating heart. Two years from now, we’ll have saved enough to start renovating. We’ll replace the fraying electrical wiring and pull down the uninsulated walls to rebuild them for Chicago winters. Behind the dining room plaster, we’ll find a shape curled at the foot of the original framing. We’ll brush away dirt and dust, then draw out a cat’s thick spine and connected skull as carefully as surgeons. There will be no other bones. The spine will be curled tightly in on itself. I dream that your teeth have caved in. We’re on a grassy hill, my head in your lap, your face framed by the sky. You’re making plans with someone I can’t see. Your upper teeth are crushed and healed, not bloody. They fold toward the roof of your mouth, leaving your top lip slack. You catch me looking. “What?” you ask, impatient in a way you aren’t when you’re awake. “What happened to your teeth?” You press your fingers to your face and feel the limp lip. “I don’t know. Why do you care? It’s nothing.” Then you return to your plans. In the dream, the injury belongs to your past and means nothing to you—until I make you notice it. When you first start traveling often for work, I fear you’ll cheat. Not an affair you intend to have, but a mistake: meeting someone in a gray corporate bar in Los Angeles, getting drunk together in an Uber back to the hotel, sleeping with a coworker after long days on the road. Are those ordinary fears in a marriage, or am I picking up on something real? Do I stop being your partner when I’m not there in front of you?

Millwork

The windows look fairly new when we first tour the house. We discover their condition only when winter arrives: the plastic shrinks, no longer stretches to fit the frames, and the Scotch tape we’ve pulled away turns out to have been holding the windows in place. One evening, we return to find the living room window lying face-down on the couch. The room is cold. Leaves are scattered across the carpet.

Ramona Room

I claim the small north-facing front bedroom as my office. Two walls are dark red, one cyan, and one yellow. Wooden craft letters spelling *Ramona Room* are glued to the door. I wonder whether she chose primary colors on purpose, and whether the glitter glue on the hardwood belongs to a daughter or granddaughter with the same name. It takes months to notice the old hasp mounted outside the door, where someone once threaded a padlock. Why did Ramona lock this room? She marked it as hers alone. Was she keeping curious children away from something? If so, why use her first name instead of “grandmother,” “aunt,” “mother,” or “Mrs”? Was Maximeno the person she wanted to keep out of this color-wheel room?

Cloud Room (Attic)

A few months after we move in, I take the stairwell painting down and carry it to the attic. I’ve started painting with oils again and want a smooth glass surface for mixing colors. The frame is heavy. I mean to pry it open and remove the glass, but the back is professionally glued and papered shut. I’m impatient to paint, so I squeeze burnt sienna, ultramarine, and titanium white onto the glass. The colors cover the figures’ faces and blur the Roman numerals that once marked time. The house has drawn me back to painting, a practice I let fade in the early pandemic. Its dizzying colors remind me how easy and joyful it can be to put paint on a blank surface. My studio is a small attic room with cerulean walls, no heat, and a broken window. Maximeno and Ramona covered each ceiling tile with peel-and-stick clouds. Through the teal door, it feels like entering a place with a paper sky instead of a roof. Before my remote workday begins, I climb up alone to paint green landscapes and peach-colored limbs. In January, frost grows thick on the window’s inner pane, which rattles in the wind. My brush slips off the canvas and paper, leaving peach, white, and red marks on the blue walls. Like Ramona, I’ve found a room of my own—and I’m leaving evidence that I was here.

Front Porch

We sit in the teak folding chairs we found for the porch. Above the tight row of houses, the sky is blue and the breeze is clear. We’ve just come back from a friend’s wedding in the Wisconsin woods. A little hungover, we trade stories about the drunkest bridesmaid, the talkative aunts and their mysterious sources of money, and the feverish memories of wood-fired pizza.

What unsettles me most isn’t that you can’t picture our wedding. It’s realizing that the history I thought we carried together may live, in detail, mostly with me.

When I complain again about my father insisting on a sit-down dinner instead of pizza at our Oregon wedding, you stare at me blankly. You don’t remember the argument, or what we ate. You remember that the wedding happened and that it was wonderful, but not what it looked like. I’m angry for a moment, then ashamed of my anger. You’ve explained before how your memory works. Knowing that doesn’t make the gap easier to face.

A past without pictures

We find a word for it: aphantasia. One of us comes across a video about a man who feels guilty because he doesn’t grieve his recently deceased mother as his family does. He loved her, the video explains, but his difficulty summoning mental images is tied to how he experiences memory and emotion. You recognize yourself in that account.

You can’t call up the shape of your childhood home or your parents’ faces. The past is a collection of facts you know belong to you, but they arrive without pictures. Your attention stays with what’s in front of you: the job, the person beside you, the immediate moment. That difference helps explain why you remember our wedding as something good without being able to replay its details.

You visit your hometown alone and spend an evening around a bonfire with Dustin, one of your closest high school friends. His dogs move through the dark behind you. You tell him your childhood feels hard to remember and ask what he recalls.

Dustin gives you the afternoons back: the road signs you stole, the turtles you found in backyard ponds. You listen, high and laughing, and keep asking for specifics. Where were you? Who else was there? What happened when you got caught? You retain the broad outlines—the rock that split his foot and sent him for stitches, the name of your prom date—but not her dress, the room, or the songs everyone shouted along to. Dustin remembers those details. Later, you tell me you held on to every word he said.

What a house keeps

We’ve been in the house six months and still haven’t found the water shutoff. We need it now: there’s no washing machine, and we’ve finally saved enough to pay a plumber to install hookups and a drain. The valve we’re allowed to operate may be somewhere in the crawlspace, a narrow run beneath the house that ranges from two feet high to barely twelve inches. Its entrance is a dark square in the hall closet floor.

We prepare for the crawlspace as if it might fight back. We buy Tyvek suits, thick gloves, goggles, duct tape, respirators, and headlamps. There could be animals, mold or fungus disturbed from the dirt, rusted metal in the dark—or simply too little room to get out again.

You go in first to look around. When you return, you’re holding a yellow goose skull, its long, flat beak still attached. We turn it over in our gloved hands. The beak shifts on what remains of the dried cartilage or tendons. We have no idea how it got into a sealed space beneath the house, or what brought the other bones there. That part of the past won’t explain itself.

But the wedding comes back to me whole. We danced until the bartender had to stop serving alcohol by law, and until our younger friends’ parents waited with tired faces to take them home. Brian, my high school friend, took vape hits behind the bar tent and tried more than once to replace the playlist with his experimental rave tracks. College friends slipped into the fir trees in pairs to smoke and kiss, returning with lipstick on their faces and mud on their shoes. As the bartender headed to her car, she winked at me and left a corkscrew beside the wine.

For the last stretch of the night, you and I held each other on the dance floor, our heads against each other’s shoulders. Friends asked if they should start packing up. We said yes, but they urged us to keep dancing while they folded the dirty tablecloths, blew out candles, and took down the string lights. “We love you,” they told us. The floor went dark around us, one small task at a time.

Like ants pressed between panes of glass, we crawl beneath the kitchen toward the living room, lowering our heads under the joists.

After learning how your memory works, I start to feel responsible for preserving our shared history for both of us. It weighs more than the worries I used to have when you traveled for work and I feared you might become closer to someone else. I’d assumed our marriage was a structure built from memories we both held. Now I see that some of its details may rest mostly with me, and I don’t know how sound that structure is.

That realization makes me doubt my own recollections. I want to write everything down, or be hypnotized in the hope that something more from the wedding might surface. Until now, I’d thought we had an unspoken arrangement: we would each have the other’s stories to help shape our own.

Here, in the present

Your movements have always seemed quick and instinctive, like a brush moving across a canvas. You reach for what’s tangible. At the grocery store, you run your hands along the watermelon bins, wipe dust from cans, and steal grapes from their bags. You leave with a list of four things and return with one, distracted by everything around you.

I can sink into memory; you seem built for the moment at hand. Maybe that comes from genetics, childhood, or something else. I can’t say. But it’s hard not to see a trade: attention to the color of produce and the small print on a label, at the cost of a past that doesn’t come with images. The explanation doesn’t make the loss feel smaller. It does help me see what your attention gives you.

We put on our protective gear and lower ourselves into the crawlspace. The soil is loose and soft with dirt, insect waste, and old cobwebs. We crawl beneath the kitchen, our respirator filters clicking with every breath. You head toward the west wall; I follow the pipes on the east, searching for the shutoff. One is a gas line. I can’t find a valve on the other.

I turn around and scoot back toward the entrance, kicking loose bricks as I go. When I call for you, there’s no answer. I shout again; your reply comes back muffled. For a few seconds, I imagine you hurt or trapped between the earth and the floor joists.

Then you emerge from the dark, a rustle of Tyvek. I can tell from your eyes that you’re smiling. You’re here, right beside me, as you so often are. Your gloved hand reaches for mine.

The post Fixing Up Our Home Means Making Memories My Husband Might Lose appeared first on Electric Literature.