The sharpest mystery in Anton Corbijn’s “A Talent for Murder” isn’t who committed a crime. It’s what makes people invent stories about one another—and how quickly those stories can turn dangerous. That shift from solving a case to probing a character gives the film its Patricia Highsmith flavor, while Helen Mirren and Alden Ehrenreich supply its most compelling contest.
A difficult author, an uncertain assignment
Mirren plays a fictionalized Highsmith in a Swiss home nicknamed “the bunker,” where she spends her days smoking, grimacing at her typewriter and making her visitor wonder whether he’s welcome—or being studied. The film draws on a few details of Highsmith’s life, including her prickly reputation and secluded final years, then lets playwright Joanna Murray-Smith build a story of psychological pressure and possible murder around them.
The visitor is Edward Ridgeway, played by Ehrenreich, a young editor sent by Highsmith’s publisher to secure a contract for one more Tom Ripley novel. He’s the second editor to make the trip. The first editor’s visit ended badly, though the film holds back the details and lets that history hang over Edward’s arrival. His job sounds straightforward: get Highsmith to write, or return without the deal his publisher wants.
Edward looks poorly equipped for the task. He’s shy, a little disheveled and visibly out of place. Highsmith seems to agree. Yet Mirren’s performance gives the author an unnerving advantage: she appears to know Edward before he has shown her much, and occasionally narrates events as if she might be shaping them. The film keeps open the possibility that she’s not simply receiving a visitor. She may be writing him, too.
That uncertainty fits a story adapted from Murray-Smith’s play “Switzerland,” which is itself concerned with Highsmith’s imagination and its effects. Rather than treating the author’s fiction as a puzzle to be solved, the film uses it as a method of reading people. Edward and Highsmith trade stories, probe for vulnerabilities and watch for signs that the other has given something away.
The duel gives the film its charge
Corbijn’s film comes into focus when Mirren and Ehrenreich share the screen. Highsmith’s home is arranged like a warning: poisons sit in the pantry, knives and guns have their place in the office, and even the aquarium of snails seems open to suspicion. Edward knows enough to be wary, but he doesn’t retreat. He’ll buy Highsmith a knife. He’ll eat breakfast made beside a bottle of poison. His willingness to stay makes their scenes feel like a contest with shifting rules.
Mirren makes Highsmith a formidable opponent without reducing her to a collection of sinister gestures. Her character is prickly and watchful, but the performance also suggests an author who enjoys controlling the terms of an encounter. Ehrenreich answers with a performance built around adjustment. Edward can seem meek in one moment and stubborn in the next; his manner changes depending on who’s watching. That flexibility lets the film keep us guessing about how much of his apparent awkwardness is real.
The result is a two-hander powered by mutual suspicion. Neither character has to announce that they’re testing the other. A pause, a question or an object in the room can do the work. Dimitri Capuani’s design gives Highsmith’s bunker a suitably enclosed feel, while Corbijn keeps directing attention toward details that may take on new meaning: Edward’s bag, an agitated man at the airport, a knife, or the tag on Clementine’s luggage.
Those clues don’t just point toward a conventional answer. They train the audience to reconsider what it has already seen. Corbijn makes the act of looking part of the entertainment, building a mystery that depends on interpretation as much as information.
Ripley becomes a story within the story
Edward’s trip also brings him into contact with Clementine, played by Olivia Cooke. They first meet on the train to Switzerland, then encounter each other again. Their connection gives the film another strand, and Cooke’s presence sets up a knowing echo of Highsmith’s “Strangers on a Train.” The reference is playful, but it also points to the film’s larger interest in how people cast one another into roles.
As Edward begins to make progress with Highsmith, the two start developing a new Ripley story together. Corbijn turns that process into a film within the film: Ehrenreich steps into Tom Ripley’s role, while Cooke becomes the character’s mark. Edward’s editorial assignment and the fictional crime plot begin to reflect each other, making the creative collaboration part of the suspense.
This arrangement gives Ehrenreich a chance to show how quickly he can shift between identities. His Ripley scenes are lively, and the Rome sequences with Cooke bring a different kind of pleasure to the film. But the transformation also changes the balance. The more time the story spends away from Highsmith and Edward’s verbal sparring, the less concentrated its central tension becomes.
A mystery that resists tidy answers
Murray-Smith’s script keeps several lines of action moving: Edward’s effort to secure the contract, his growing connection with Clementine, and the Ripley plot taking shape on the page and on screen. The structure is playful and controlled, but it can thin out the energy that made the early scenes so absorbing. Ehrenreich’s performance as Ripley is entertaining; his exchanges with Mirren are more revealing.
That imbalance doesn’t erase the film’s pleasures. “A Talent for Murder” is interested in the gap between what people show and what they might intend, and it lets that uncertainty linger instead of forcing every thread into a neat explanation. The mystery may not settle into a single, clean solution. Here, that feels less like a failure to close the case than a choice to keep the audience inside Highsmith’s preferred territory: the uncomfortable question of why someone behaves as they do.
The film premiered at the 2026 Toronto International Film Festival. Bleecker Street is scheduled to release it in theaters on Friday, October 23. Its clearest strength is already on display: when Highsmith and Edward are trying to outread each other, the film has a nimble, teasing pulse. That duel is the reason to follow its many turns.