A decade after Moonlight reached audiences, its writer Tarell Alvin McCraney still sees the film as an invitation to ask a searching question: “Who am I and who can I be?” Its lasting influence, in his view, comes from how closely it looks at Black queer life—and from the creative permission it gave others to make images of their own.
The film opened on October 21, ten years before McCraney discussed its legacy in an interview with IndieWire. Directed by Barry Jenkins, it won the Academy Award for Best Picture, while McCraney received the Oscar for Best Adapted Screenplay. He says revisiting it remains worthwhile: “Seeing it now is worth the price of admission.”
A story first written in grief
The project began in 2003, shortly after McCraney’s mother died from AIDS-related complications. He wrote an early version under the title In Moonlight Black Boys Look Blue, a story rooted in memories of growing up in Miami’s Liberty City. At the same time, he was preparing an application to Yale School of Drama and writing The Brothers Size, the play that became part of that application.
McCraney had learned to think about the form a story should take from his high-school teacher, Rafael Lima. Lima’s advice was simple: stories that arrive visually may belong on screen; stories that come through sound may be plays. McCraney saw this one in images, but the early screenplay was neither a short nor a full feature. He describes it as a “medium length.”
Writing was also a way to assemble memories after loss. McCraney had previously made a high-school short called Silent Type, and says both projects grew from the effort to recall his earliest experiences. The original screenplay stayed on his computer for roughly a decade. Attempts to make it in Chicago, involving people including actor André Holland and Glenn Davis of Steppenwolf, didn’t take the story to the screen.
In 2012 or 2013, McCraney met Jenkins at a Miami film festival. They discovered they had grown up only blocks apart. Their mutual friend Andrew Hevia had passed Jenkins the screenplay, and Jenkins proposed turning it into a feature. McCraney agreed. The filmmaker kept gathering support and returning to the idea; McCraney says Jenkins later told him he needed to hear that agreement several times before believing it.
What Jenkins brought to the material, McCraney says, was a way to make memory feel present and tangible. The resulting film took a story built from personal recollection and shaped it into something audiences could experience together.
Miami’s role in the film’s path
McCraney credits Miami arts organization YoungArts with helping cultivate the local creative community around him. As a student, he would slip out of playwriting class to watch YoungArts finalists perform. Seeing dancers at work made him think about the discipline and control involved in mastering an artistic form—and about what he needed to bring to his own practice.
YoungArts also helped connect the people who would make Moonlight. Hevia, a former arts finalist, introduced McCraney and Jenkins because both had Miami ties. The organization later gave the film’s team space for pre-production. For McCraney, that kind of sustained support for artists matters: it helps local work take shape and brings artists into contact with one another.
The film’s Miami setting was personal in another way. McCraney wasn’t on set, in part because so many filming locations were places where he had lived or grown up. Watching scenes in screening rooms, he felt grateful that those places and memories had been captured by the filmmakers. Seeing the finished work at the Toronto International Film Festival changed the experience again: he realized he was sharing that personal history with an audience of about 2,200 people.
He had expected the film to reach a few hundred thousand viewers, drawing on his experience with independent cinema in Miami. Instead, its audience grew far beyond that, potentially into the millions. Even years later, McCraney says he can be surprised when people want to discuss the film.
Performances that carried personal weight
Mahershala Ali had crossed paths with McCraney before the film. Ali had been considered for a role in McCraney’s play In the Red and Brown Water, but another production prevented them from working together then. When Jenkins raised Ali for the role of Juan, McCraney immediately felt the casting made sense. Juan drew on someone who had deeply influenced McCraney when he was young, and he trusted Ali to bring the character to life.
Naomie Harris’s work as Paula demanded a different kind of attention. McCraney says she had only three or four days on set for her material, but committed fully to the role. Some scenes were difficult for him to watch because Paula’s struggles echoed his mother’s experience. He especially appreciated Jenkins retaining and expanding the screenplay’s reconciliation between mother and son. Harris, he says, took on the character’s pain rather than softening it.
Closeness as a creative influence
For McCraney, one of the film’s central contributions is its intimacy. The camera’s closeness to its characters—the sustained attention to their faces and eyes—lets viewers sit with a kind of vulnerability that he felt was rarely seen in depictions of Black queer people. The film’s images invite the audience to spend time with Chiron, rather than keeping emotional distance from him.
He points to the baptism scene, in which Juan baptizes Little, as one example of the film’s rituals and closeness. He also sees the camera’s attention as part of a longer cinematic tradition, recalling the intimacy of films such as Ordinary People. The effect, he says, showed other filmmakers that they could approach subjects with similar openness while finding their own visual language.
That example reached beyond directors. After the film’s release, McCraney heard from people who began studying film, taking up cinematography or pursuing photography more seriously. He connects that response to the personal need behind the project: he wanted to see aspects of himself represented. Other people recognized that need and felt encouraged to make work that might answer it for themselves.
The production also arrived amid wider access to filmmaking tools. McCraney says the ability to create and distribute visual work had expanded, and his next film was shot on an iPhone. Moonlight became part of a period when aspiring artists could see a path into filmmaking and begin experimenting in their own forms.
Adaptation, authorship and an unexpected ending
McCraney regards the Oscar for adapted screenplay as a fitting recognition. Jenkins reorganized the original material, which had presented the different stages of Chiron’s life in a more circular structure. In the screenplay, viewers would see Little, Chiron and Black performing similar morning routines before realizing they were watching one person at different ages. Jenkins instead divided the story into chapters and told it more linearly.
He also reshaped the film’s final stretch, expanding the last 20 to 30 minutes with details Jenkins drew from his own life, McCraney says. The adaptation was therefore a close collaboration: it preserved the story’s foundation while changing its structure and adding new material. McCraney says he hopes they have another chance to work together.
The film’s Oscar-night Best Picture mix-up remains part of its history. McCraney doesn’t believe the episode has diminished the movie itself. He describes it as something that happened and cannot be undone, then recalls advice he gave his friend Jeremy Pope: “If you don’t count it all joy, then you won’t stop counting.” For McCraney, the anniversary is a chance to recognize the work and the people behind it—and to keep asking what new stories they might make next.
McCraney, now artistic director of the Geffen Playhouse, says he continues to work on film and television projects he can’t yet discuss. He describes himself as still expanding, and sees creative growth as a reason not to settle inside the recognition of one film. Ten years on, Moonlight remains both a record of particular memories and a prompt for artists to make images that audiences have been waiting to see.