How to Make Better Pie, According to Pastry Chef Melissa Weller

Good pie depends on a handful of small decisions. Cold butter, restrained mixing, a proper rest, and enough time in the oven can make the difference between a sturdy, flaky crust and a disappointing one. Those details are easy to miss in a recipe—and they’re often what experienced bakers learn by doing.

Pastry chef Melissa Weller shares the techniques she uses for pies that look polished and taste good, from mixing and rolling dough to crimping the edge and judging when the filling is done. Her advice also appears in this guide to homemade pie crust and her book A Good Bake, written with Carolyn Carreno.

A flaky lattice crust on a bourbon caramel apple pie.

A Good Bake by Melissa Weller with Carolyn Carreno is listed for $38 at Amazon and Bookshop, reduced from $40.

How to make flaky pie crust

Start with great pie dough.

Choose a dough that suits the pie

A pie crust’s texture starts with the kind of dough you make. My usual choice is pâte brisée: “brisée” means “broken,” a reference to butter rubbed into flour. Those butter pieces create the layers that bake up flaky. For a sweeter, more cookie-like shell, pâte sucrée uses sugar and egg, with butter and sugar creamed together.

Plan ahead

Resting time is part of the recipe. Bakeries often make dough days before they need it; at home, that head start gives the dough time to chill and makes it ready to roll when you are. You can also freeze pie dough for up to one month. Wrap it well and thaw it overnight in the refrigerator.

Pick your fat

Pie dough needs flour, water, salt, fat, and sometimes a little sugar. Many traditional American recipes use lard, rendered pork fat that can produce an especially flaky crust. I like lard, but good-quality lard can be hard to find. For my pies and tarts, I use unsalted butter. Handle it well and you can get a flaky crust with the buttery flavor, too.
A baker working butter into flour to make pie dough.
Some big pieces, some smaller pieces, just right. Christopher Testani

Keep the butter cold and in pieces

Many pie recipes recommend cutting butter into ¼-inch cubes. I prefer pieces closer to ½ inch. Spread them on a plate and freeze for 10 minutes: they should be very cold, but not rock-hard. Those larger pieces matter. Some stay intact as you mix and roll, leaving streaks of butter through the dough. In the oven, the butter’s water turns to steam and helps form thin, flaky layers. Want even more flake? See our guide to laminating pie dough →

Add cold water, then stop mixing early

Refrigerator-cold water works for me; you don’t need to fetch ice water, though extra-chilled water is fine. Add it only after combining the flour and butter. Once water meets flour, gluten begins to develop. Too much gluten can leave the crust dense and tough. Coating flour with cold butter first slows that interaction. Don’t aim for a smooth, uniform dough like cookie dough. Stop when it just starts to come together. The mixture should still look shaggy, with visible butter chunks and some crumbly bits; those dry patches will absorb moisture as the dough rests.
A baking transferring shaggy pie dough to a surface for kneading.
It’s okay if there are still some floury bits! Photo by Christopher Testani

Rest before rolling

Shape the dough into a disk or a brick to match how you plan to roll it. Wrap it, press it flatter with a rolling pin, and refrigerate. Resting gives the flour time to take up moisture and relaxes the gluten, so the dough rolls more easily and is less likely to shrink in the oven. Warm kitchens call for quicker handling and longer chills. If the dough turns soft or tacky, put it back in the refrigerator. Chilling the bowl, bench scraper, and rolling pin before you begin can help, too.

How to roll out pie crust

Work quickly, but let the dough soften slightly

Take the dough from the refrigerator and wait 10 to 15 minutes, until it’s pliable but still firm. Too cold, and it may crack; too warm, and it can stick. While it rests, clear your counter and gather a rolling pin, plus any tools the recipe calls for: a bench knife, cutter, straightedge, pastry wheel, or knife. Have flour—or sometimes sugar—for dusting, and prepare the pie plate or parchment-lined baking sheet so the rolled dough can go straight to assembly. Once you start, keep moving. Friction and warm hands soften dough fast; rolling should take a minute or two.

How to shape and crimp pie crust

Butter the plate and transfer the dough gently

I butter the bottom and sloped sides of the pie plate before lining it. It helps the crust stay put while I shape it and can make the baked pie easier to remove. A visible coating is enough; cold butter works, though slightly softened butter is fine. For a round pie plate, fold the dough in half and lift it into the pan. For a larger sheet, such as one for a jelly roll pan, roll it around your pin and carry it over. Either way, center the dough above the dish, lower it gently, then unfold or unroll it.
Hands fitting pie dough into a pie dish.
Ease the pie dough into the bottom corners of the pan without stretching it. Photograph by Isa Zapata, Food Styling by Kaitlin Wayne

Fit, trim, and crimp

Lift one edge at a time and press the dough into the pan’s bottom and sides. Don’t pull it to make it fit: stretched dough can snap back in the oven and leave thin spots. Press it lightly onto the rim and check that the overhang is even. Trim the bottom crust with kitchen shears, leaving about 1 inch beyond the edge. Save the scraps by pressing them into a disk and refrigerating or freezing them for another pie. For a double-crust pie or a lattice-topped pie, trim the top crust or lattice flush with the pan’s outside edge. To crimp, roll the overhang toward the center until it forms a thick ridge on the rim. I fold the dough up and over itself, rather than under; when you’re done, no dough should hang over the edge. For a double crust, roll the bottom edge over the top crust to seal the filling in. Shape the ridge into an even curve, then pinch around the edge with your fingers to form a repeating V or U.
A person's hands crimping an allbutter pie dough lining a glass pie plate.
Keep it even: Place your thumb in the indent from your index finger just made.

Chill the assembled pie

Pie dough gets chilled at several points: after mixing, after lining the dish, and again after crimping and filling. That repetition pays off. A cold pie holds its shape better in the oven, which goes a long way toward explaining why bakery crusts often look neater. In my kitchens, we sometimes freeze a fully assembled fruit pie overnight, then bake it from frozen. Put it straight into the oven and add 10 to 20 minutes to the recipe’s baking time, checking the recipe’s visual cues for doneness.

How to bake a pie properly

Give it a stage

Set a baking sheet beneath the pie before it goes into the oven. Fruit juices can bubble over the pan, and the sheet catches the spill before it reaches the oven floor.

Blind-bake when the filling calls for it

Blind baking gives the crust a head start. Custard fillings often need only a partial bake, which helps prevent a soggy bottom or a raw center. For tarts and pies with fillings that won’t go into the oven, bake the shell until it’s fully golden. Line the crimped, unbaked shell with parchment—crumpling the paper first makes it easier to fit—then add pie weights so the dough doesn’t puff. BA’s favorite weights are inexpensive steel ball bearings; dried beans or rice work too. Mark any food you use for this job as “pie weights” afterward. Baking leaves them unsuitable for cooking. For the full method, see BA’s guide to blind-baking pie crust.

Judge doneness by what you see

Oven timing is an estimate. A cold pie, hot spots, and the quirks of your oven all affect how long it needs, so visual cues matter more than the clock. Look for a deeply golden crust. A fruit pie should bubble in the center, through a lattice or a vent; bubbling only at the edges means the fruit hasn’t cooked down enough. Pull it too soon and the filling may weep when sliced. Custard has a different signal: it should wobble gently when you move the pan, without sloshing. Bake it until fully firm and cracks may appear as it cools. Then wait. Custard needs time to set and may need several hours in the refrigerator; fruit filling also needs time to gel. If you want slices that hold together, cooling is part of the recipe.

Pie crust troubleshooting

Why is my crust tough? Too much mixing or handling builds gluten and can leave the crust tough. Stop when the dough starts to come together; a shaggy look and visible butter pieces are fine. Why did the crust shrink or slump? Dough may shrink if it hasn’t rested, or if you stretch it into the pan. Rest it in the refrigerator before rolling, ease it gently into the dish, then chill the shaped crust before baking. A slump can also mean the weights came out too early or didn’t reach the rim. Keep them in until the crust looks set and dry and the parchment no longer sticks. Why isn’t the crust flaky? Warm butter, or butter worked too thoroughly into the flour, can erase the layers. Keep the butter cold and leave some larger pieces intact. If the dough turns soft or tacky, chill it until firm. Why does the dough crack as I roll it? It may be too cold, or it may not have enough moisture. Let chilled dough become pliable while staying firm. If it still crumbles and won’t hold together, it may need more hydration.

Ready to bake?

41 Pie Recipes for Any and Every Occasion — They’ll be here whenever you need them.