For food editor Rebecca Firkser, the phrase “food is fuel” once flattened something she loved into a mechanical task. Food meant pleasure, memory and gathering. But after years of restrictive eating and exhausting workouts, she began to see that nourishment also had a practical role: giving her body enough energy to run, lift and recover.

That shift took time. Firkser describes a long stretch of bingeing and restricting, with food treated as a reward or punishment. Therapy helped her build a less painful relationship with eating, but supplying her body with enough food remained difficult. She had become accustomed to underfueling and assumed that exhaustion after a run or strength session was normal.

When healthy eating means eating enough

Training changed the question she was asking. Rather than focusing only on whether a meal looked “healthy,” Firkser began to consider whether it provided enough carbohydrates, protein and fat to support exercise and recovery. Eating for stamina, harder lifts or longer runs meant rethinking ingredients she had once regarded with suspicion.

Bread, cheese, white potatoes and red meat can all contribute nourishment, she found. That didn’t require abandoning vegetables, legumes or other foods she enjoyed. It meant loosening the all-or-nothing rules that had made individual ingredients seem like obstacles to good health.

Those rules had formed early. When Firkser learned that red meat contains more saturated fat than legumes, she cut back on meat. Concern that carbohydrates could affect blood sugar, hunger or weight led her to replace morning oatmeal with yogurt. She had no medical reason to make those restrictions; she was trying to meet a narrow ideal of health that, in her mind, was closely tied to being thin.

Exercise followed the same logic. She spent hours doing cardio without a clear training goal, aiming to burn calories while eating as little as possible. That routine left little room for the idea that activity might call for more food. Now, as she runs and strength trains, the connection is harder to ignore: an active body needs energy to do the work.

Food thoughts, hunger and weight-loss culture

Firkser’s change in perspective comes amid a renewed emphasis on weight loss. She points to the growing public profile of GLP-1 drugs and weight-loss treatments, including discussion of using them to shed a few pounds. Her concern is not with people taking prescribed medication for a medical need. Some users, she acknowledges, say treatment has helped them exercise comfortably, reduce alcohol use or manage binge-eating disorder.

What troubles her is the casual talk of taking these drugs without a medical need, including to lose a final five or 10 pounds. She also worries about how people interpret “food noise,” a loosely defined term for food thoughts that feel intrusive and interrupt daily life.

For someone with a history of disordered eating, ordinary thoughts about food can start to look like a problem. Hunger is one reason food comes to mind, and Firkser argues that feeling hungry during the day can be a normal response to the body’s energy needs. If the goal becomes forgetting about food altogether, the underlying shame around eating deserves attention too.

Her point is not that medication itself explains or causes those concerns. It’s that reducing appetite can sound appealing in a culture that treats hunger as a failure and thinness as proof of health. For Firkser, that framing risks obscuring a more basic question: why should someone feel ashamed to eat enough?

A more flexible way to eat for activity

Firkser’s current guide is simple: hunger is human, and being able to satisfy it is a privilege. She wants to notice what her body can do when it’s well nourished, even if her strongest and most capable body isn’t her leanest one. And she doesn’t want to lose her appetite just to quiet every thought about food.

That outlook doesn’t mean she has adopted a rigid athlete’s menu. She doesn’t plan to eat only chicken breast or beef because gym culture favors those foods. She cooks meat perhaps once or twice a week and also eats seafood and plant-based proteins. She isn’t counting macronutrients with strict precision; she’s learning what different foods offer and making room for variety.

A meal built around a russet potato and ground beef can sit alongside legumes, grains, chicken breast or sardines. The mix matters more than labeling one ingredient virtuous and another forbidden. Firkser’s wider point is that a varied diet can include foods she once avoided, especially when she’s using her body actively.

Her appetite can change with her schedule. On a particularly active day, she may eat more and appreciate the extra energy. On a quieter day, she no longer believes she has to restrict food because she hasn’t “earned” it through exercise. Food is part of meeting the body’s needs, not a prize for completing a workout.

Firkser also challenges the assumption that fewer calories always mean better health. She notes that intentional underfueling can prompt the body to conserve energy. Calories, in her framing, are a measure of energy rather than something inherently shameful. The practical lesson is not to follow one universal meal plan, but to stop treating sustenance as conditional on activity.

Fuel for the body and the mind

The phrase “food is fuel” still doesn’t capture everything Firkser values about eating. A meal can be nourishing and pleasurable, familiar and new. After a 10K, she wants food that supports recovery; after writing, she wants nourishment for her brain. Either way, she wants something she actually craves, whether it’s salty or sweet, rich or crunchy.

For Firkser, the meaningful change was allowing those ideas to coexist. Food can bring people together and carry memories, while also giving the body energy for daily life. Her experience suggests a concrete takeaway for active people: eating enough is part of building strength and stamina, and a healthy approach has room for both nourishment and enjoyment.

More from Rebecca’s Good for You column