
Frontispiece from The School of Venus, or the Ladies Delight (1680), by Michel Millot, via Google Books. Public Domain.
Early modern writers gave the dildo a literary life that stretched well beyond a joke about sex. It could be a prized imported object, an unruly rival to men, a target of political satire and, in the hands of women, evidence of desires that courts struggled to name. The surviving poems and objects suggest a culture fascinated by the device—and uneasy about what it made possible.
A glass rival in a London brothel
One of the earliest appearances of the word “dildoe” in English literature comes in Thomas Nashe’s erotic poem The Choise of Valentines, written in the early 1590s. Its protagonist, Tomalin, visits his lover Mistress Francis in a brothel on Valentine’s Day. He pays the madam and rushes upstairs, but his confidence outlasts his performance only briefly. Francis, left unsatisfied, turns to a device she calls her “little dildoe.”
Nashe makes the object a competitor with a personality. Francis’s “knave” is dependable where Tomalin is not: it stays firm, won’t cause pregnancy and doesn’t tire or rush. She describes it as a better lover, and Tomalin responds as if another man has taken his place. He calls it a filthy counterfeit and imagines it deserving a whipping. The poem’s mock-epic treatment turns an intimate object into a swaggering bedroom rival.
It also gives the device a specific material form. Francis’s dildo is made from “thick congealed glasse,” wrapped in white silk and designed to produce pleasure with precision. That detail may sound like comic invention, yet glass examples associated with early modern Europe survive in museum collections in Trier and Paris. Venetian glassmakers on Murano were renowned for clear cristallo and glass that imitated precious stone. Nashe’s reference to “forraine artes” points toward the prestige of imported craft.
The idea has a parallel in the Italian poet Pietro Aretino’s erotic writing. In a dialogue set in a Venetian convent, a boy brings nuns a basket of translucent glass fruit: carrots, quinces, turnips and other shapes. The women call these objects pastinaca muranese, or “Murano parsnips.” The joke’s euphemism captures a broader pattern: writers often made sexual objects legible through food, foreignness and luxury.
From private pleasure to public satire
The word’s own origin remains uncertain. It may have circulated first in bawdy refrains and tavern songs, amid nonsense phrases such as nonny-nonny, ding-a-ding and fa la la. Later writers connected “dildoe” with the Italian diletto, meaning delight, while dictionaries eventually described it as a penis succedaneus, or substitute penis. The shifting explanations fit an object that was frequently discussed through euphemism and disguise.
During the Restoration, that disguise moved into public view. Charles II returned from French exile in 1660, theaters reopened after Puritan rule, and courtly pleasure became a conspicuous subject of writing and gossip. London’s coffeehouses, playhouses and pleasure gardens provided new settings for sexual wit. In poems and lampoons, the dildo could now appear not just as a private possession but as a character circulating through the city and court.
One poem introduces “a noble Italian called Signior Dildo,” whose talents make him popular among court ladies. They worship him, hide him in sleeves and steal him from their mothers, the poet claims. His appeal rests partly on his silence and obedience: unlike the men he displaces, he is “ready and dumb.” Another poem recasts him as “Monsieur Thing,” a Frenchman who travels through women’s beds and rises through society like an ambitious lover. Both characters are called “Rival,” a label that makes the joke’s point plain: women might prefer the device to husbands, lovers or courtiers.
These poems used the figure to mock concerns about aristocratic indulgence, women’s desire, foreign influence and the court’s weakness. They also left a record of commerce. Dildos appear for sale in Covent Garden toy shops and on St. James’s Street, among powder, gloves and perfume. At the Royal Exchange, poems place them alongside imported luxuries such as scented gloves, tortoiseshell snuffboxes and velvet beauty patches. Materials included horn, ivory and bone; coverings of satin, velvet or taffeta were meant to enhance sensation. One writer even distinguishes models for “tender Virgins” from those intended for the “wide salacious Slit.”
The School of Venus, an erotic dialogue that reached London from France, presents another version of the period’s sexual instruction. It discusses pleasure objects, including a life-size bronze lover with an erect, red-tipped penis. The book’s readership was not limited to women: Samuel Pepys bought a copy on the Strand in 1668. He described it as “rogueish,” took it home and recorded masturbating to it in his diary, using the coded phrase “una vez to decharger.” He then burned the volume.
Objects that imitate—and outlast—the body
As the literature grew more elaborate, so did its descriptions of likeness. Some devices were painted to resemble skin, with veins and hair, and were said to come “so near to Nature.” Others contained chambers, springs and pumps that could force warm water or milk through an opening at the tip. The aim was not simply to copy a penis but to reproduce particular bodily effects.
At least one surviving object shows that such mechanisms were more than poetic conceits. An eighteenth-century ivory dildo, found hidden in the seat of an armchair at a convent near Paris, had a pump intended to simulate ejaculation. The design reflects a period belief that women’s pleasure depended partly on male emission. Its engineering makes a point that the poetry also returns to: these devices were built to compete with the body on its own terms.
Yet the physical record is thin. Leather decays, wax loses its shape and glass breaks. Even when an object survives, its use can be obscured by its catalog description. Murano glass dildos have been classified as “hoax drinking glasses,” their hollow construction assigned to the table rather than the bedroom. A wooden phallus recovered in 1992 from a Roman fort near Hadrian’s Wall was variously proposed as a pestle or a protective carving; for decades, it was catalogued as a “darning tool.”
Other objects were deliberately destroyed. In 1672, customs officers found a hogshead of contraband French dildos, broke open the barrel and burned its contents in a marketplace. The public bonfire inspired Dildoides, a mock epic that casts the confiscated cargo as a fallen Troy and laments, “O barbarous Times, where Deities are made themselves a Sacrifice.” The poem turns censorship into spectacle, keeping the objects alive in words even as the goods went up in flames.
The woman behind the object
The dildo’s comic career had a more threatening counterpart. In the fifteenth century, the German inquisitor Heinrich Kramer’s Malleus Maleficarum, or The Hammer of Witches, described witches as stealing men’s penises through supernatural glamour. The victims were left with “nothing but his smooth body,” while the stolen organs supposedly lived in captivity, fed with oats and kept in nests or boxes. The fantasy turns male sexual loss into a form of female power.
Its anxiety reaches beyond the loss of men’s bodies. It imagines women possessing and using phallic objects, and therefore having sexual relationships with women without men. A rare court record gives that possibility a name and a material form. At her 1477 trial in Germany, Katherina Hetzeldorfer described making a penis from a piece of red leather and a wooden stick. She tied it around her waist with a string and used it to have sex with a married woman. The court sentenced her to death; she was thrown into the Rhine.
Records of women’s sexual relationships and gender presentation remain scattered across trial documents, legal texts, chronicles and journals. In the sixteenth century, two Spanish nuns were reportedly burned for using “material instruments.” In France, one woman was executed for the “wickedness which she used to counterfeit the office of a husband.” A weaver who lived as a man and married a woman was hanged for using “illicit devices.” By the eighteenth century, accounts increasingly described some such people as “female husbands.”
The language of the record shaped what could be seen. Courts often prosecuted women under categories such as vagrancy, perjury or breach of the peace, leaving their relationships unnamed. The dildo made sex between women recognizable to authorities by suggesting an imitation of the penile act, but it could also obscure the people who used it. Its history is therefore not only one of objects and erotic jokes. It is also a record of how women’s sexual independence surfaced in literature and testimony, then slipped from view when institutions lacked—or refused—to describe it directly.
Izabella Scott is the author of The Bed Trick: Sex and Deception on Trial (2026), published by FSG. Her writing has appeared in the Financial Times, Granta, the London Review of Books, and The World of Interiors.