I've Tried Every Meal Delivery Service and, Honestly, Only a Few Are Worth Your Money
I love to cook—which should come as no surprise considering that I work at Bon Appétit. But while I relish the opportunity to pull together an elaborate meal, the reality is that most weeknights I find myself arriving home at 7 p.m. to a sad, mostly empty fridge, and so I settle for frozen dumplings or boxed mac and cheese.
That’s where meal delivery services come in: The best ones, like Marley Spoon, make cooking weeknight meals seamless, stress-free, and fun, without the need for a weekly meal-planning sesh or trip to the grocery store. They can also introduce you to new techniques, ingredients, or hacks that’ll inform your approaches to home cooking more broadly—something boxed mac and cheese, for all its merits, could never do.
Our top picks
- Best meal kit overall: Marley Spoon
- Most customizable: Home Chef
- Best for families: HelloFresh
- Best prepared meal delivery service: CookUnity
- Most affordable: Dinnerly
- If you hate grocery shopping: Hungryroot
- Best healthy meal kit: Sunbasket
- Best organic meal kit: Green Chef
- Best plant-based: Purple Carrot
We’ve spent years rigorously testing the top players in the field in order to make recommendations that are best suited to your specific needs. Go directly to our top picks to order your weekly meals, or learn more about how our editors tested these kits.
New in this update: We named Sunbasket our recommendation for the best healthy meal kit.
- Best meal kit: Marley Spoon
- Most customizable: Home Chef
- For families: HelloFresh
- Best prepared meal delivery: CookUnity
- Most budget-friendly: Dinnerly
- If you hate grocery shopping: Hungryroot
- Healthiest: Sunbasket
- Best for organic ingredients: Green Chef
- Best plant-based: Purple Carrot
- How we tested
- What makes a good meal delivery service
- Others we’ve tested
- How do the top meal kits compare?
- FAQs
Best meal kit overall: Marley Spoon
Click here for our full review of Marley Spoon
Most customizable: Home Chef
Read our full Home Chef review
Best for families: HelloFresh
The best prepared meal delivery service: CookUnity
Click here for our full review of CookUnity
The best bang for your buck: Dinnerly
Best for people who hate grocery shopping: Hungryroot
Click here for our full review of Hungryroot
Best healthy meal kit: Sunbasket
For more of our favorite healthy meal delivery services, click here.
Best for organic ingredients: Green Chef
The best plant-based meal kit: Purple Carrot
Click here for our full Purple Carrot review
How we tested these services
At any given moment, Bon Appétit editors are probably testing a meal kit—we keep this process going perpetually to ensure that we're familiar with the ever-changing meal options the kits offer and to monitor quality and consistency over time. For the last three years, editors from across the Bon Appétit team have integrated meals from all of the companies above into their daily cooking repertoires. We also frequently have staff members retest meal kits that are new to them, so we get a variety of perspectives. Here's the process we use when conducting our testing:
Getting a feel for the ordering process
Editors select meals from the company, ensuring that they choose a wide variety of meal options that will really demonstrate everything this particular meal kit has to offer. We pay close attention to the ordering process, making note of how easy it is to sign up, whether it's possible to filter by different dietary needs, and what options are available in terms of serving size, frequency, and cuisines.
Receiving and unboxing the meal kits
We take note of any delivery mishaps or delays for each shipment. Then, after receiving the meal kit, we unbox it and examine how well items were packed, checking for damage or lost freshness and noting how much packaging waste was involved. We also compare the quality of the individual ingredients to what we'd find at the grocery store or in competing kits, then put items away in the fridge or pantry until we're ready to use them.
Cooking and eating the meal kits
When it's time to cook, we follow the provided instructions closely, making note of any unclear steps or inaccurate cook times. Many of our recipe-developing editors also test these kits in their home kitchens as part of their normal cooking routines, to see how they hold up on a busy weeknight. We plate each meal as directed, then taste, paying attention to flavor, how satisfying the meal is, and whether the portion size feels ample enough.
Long-term testing
Our reviews don't stop at a single week of testing. We regularly return to these services with fresh eyes—often assigning them to editors who haven't tried them—to account for changes in menu availability, ingredient quality, and overall experience. Services can shift significantly over time, and a meal kit that impressed us a year ago may have changed, for better or worse. When we notice meaningful differences, we update our reviews accordingly.
Who is this meal kit right for?
Different meal kits are designed to meet different needs. Some offer packaged ready-made meals that are as easy as fast food, but offer more nutritional value. Some involve just as much chopping and sautéing and cleaning up afterward as a regular recipe. The first might be great for a busy family looking to fill a few weeknight dinners with cook-free options, while the second might be perfect for someone who genuinely loves to cook and is looking for new recipes and to learn new techniques. We do judge these meal kits against one another, but we also assess them based on how well they serve the specific user needs they’re designed for.
What makes a good meal delivery service
Packaging and freshness
A good meal kit arrives on time and well-packaged, with ingredients that are undamaged and still fresh. The best kits also keep packaging waste to a minimum, steering clear of things like excess single-use plastic, and include ingredients on par with what you'd find at a well-stocked grocery store, or better.
Recipe quality
A good meal kit comes with recipes that are clear and efficient to follow, with accurate cook times and instructions precise enough to deliver consistent results, whether you're a beginner or an experienced cook. The best recipes hold up under real-world conditions, like a hectic weeknight when dinner needs to come together fast.
Taste
Taste is the most important factor in what makes a meal kit worth ordering. The best kits deliver well-balanced, flavorful dishes in portions that feel satisfying rather than skimpy.
Price
A good meal kit offers enough value, whether through convenience, ingredient quality, or ready-made ease, to justify its price relative to grocery store costs, takeout, or other kits. Meal kits carry a premium no matter what, so the best ones make that premium feel worth paying.
Other meal kits we’ve tested
There are things we liked and things we’d leave about each of the kits below. But hey—everyone’s different! So one of these might be best for you.
Blue Apron
Click here for our full review of Blue Apron
Factor
Tovala
Sakara
Click here for our full review of Sakara
Thistle
Gobble
Forkful
Click here for our full review of Forkful
Territory
Cumin Club
Tempo Meals by Home Chef
Fresh Meal Plan
Gardencup
How do the top meal kits compare?
| Marley Spoon → Jump to review | Home Chef → Jump to review | HelloFresh → Jump to review | CookUnity → Jump to review | Dinnerly → Jump to review | Hungryroot → Jump to review | Sunbasket → Jump to review | Green Chef → Jump to review | Purple Carrot → Jump to review | |
| Cost per serving | $9 to $13 | $9+ | $10 | $12+ | $8 | $9+ | $15 | $11.99 | $13 |
| Type of meal kit | Primarily kit; heat-and-eat meals available | Primarily kit; heat-and-eat meals available | Primarily kit; heat-and-eat meals available | Fully prepared | Kit | Kit and grocery | Primarily kit; heat-and-eat meals available | Primarily kit; heat-and-eat meals available | Kit; heat-and-eat meals available as add-ons |
| Option for add-ons? | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Vegetarian/vegan-friendly? | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes; vegan only |
| Other diets they accommodate | Gluten-free, low-calorie, low-carb, picky eater–approved, quick-and-easy | Protein-packed, calorie-conscious, carb-conscious, Mediterranean, keto-friendly, gluten-smart, pescatarian | High-protein, vegan, vegetarian, Low-carb, gluten-free, plus various other nutrition preferences | Dairy-free, gluten-free, pescatarian, keto, paleo, plus various other nutrition preferences | Low-calorie, low-carb, gluten-free, “picky eaters” | Dairy-free, gluten-free, pescatarian, allergen-free, plus various other nutrition preferences | Paleo, vegetarian, gluten-free, carb-conscious, keto, Mediterranean, diabetes-friendly, pescatarian | Protein-packed, keto, gluten-free, calorie-smart | High-protein, gluten-free |
Frequently asked questions (FAQ)
What is the best meal delivery service?
The best meal delivery service for you will depend heavily on your personal needs and preferences. But if you’re looking for a traditional box-of-ingredients-style kit, Marley Spoon is a great place to start. It's our top choice for most people thanks to its diverse menu, extensive customization, and flexibility in accommodating various dietary needs.
What kinds of meal kits are there?
There are three main types of meal kits out there. Some, like Hungryroot, are curated grocery deliveries that come with recipes that you can choose to make—or not make. Others come only with specific preportioned ingredients designed to make one recipe for two to four people. And finally, there are fully premade meals that need to be popped into the oven or microwave. Of course, some meal kits are designed specifically to fit certain dietary restrictions. Then there are meal delivery services that allow you to mix and match all of the above.
How do you choose the best meal kit for you?
All of these styles of meal kits have their pros and cons, and the right one for you depends heavily on your lifestyle at the given moment that you’re shopping. So whether you’re looking for a subscription service that meets specific dietary needs, prioritizes high-quality ingredients and truly fresh meals, or offers a good selection of budget-friendly healthy meals, you’ll surely find your match in the options above.
We tried to assess the meal kits against the problems they were trying to solve for home cooks rather than straightforwardly pitting them against one another. Because a premade meal is never going to be as fresh as one you make from a kit—but it will be a lot easier, if that’s what you’re looking for. We have yet to find an affordable option that compares to the higher end meal kits on this list, but our top budget pick is still a good option for those who are budget-constrained but interested in trying out a meal delivery service.
If you’re looking for more specific meal kit requirements, read our list of the best vegetarian meal kits, the best healthy meal kits, the cheapest meal kits, and the best prepared meal kits.
Is there a difference between meal kits and meal delivery services?
A meal kit is to a meal delivery service as a square is to a rectangle—which is to say, every meal kit is a meal delivery service, but not every meal delivery service is a meal kit. Meal kits typically refer to boxes of ingredients that need assembling, whereas meal delivery services also encompass premade meals.
How much do meal delivery services cost per serving?
Cost will vary service to service, but the ones on this list range from $8 per serving to around $30.
How easy is it to cancel meal delivery services or skip a week?
This will also depend on the service at hand, but in general, most meal delivery services give you the option to pause your subscription if you need to skip a week—you just have to make sure to do so before that week’s order cutoff date.
Meal delivery services are also notorious for making it difficult to cancel your subscription, but there is always a way to do so. You should find a button to cancel in your account settings, but when in doubt, we suggest contacting customer service to assist you (because those cancel buttons can really be buried sometimes!).
Are meal delivery services worth it?
Meal delivery services ask you to pay a premium for convenience. If the time and energy (both mental and physical) saved by not needing to meal plan or grocery shop feel worth the extra dollars per serving of food, then subscribing to one of these services is absolutely worth it. They may also be worth considering if you have dietary restrictions that make weekly meal planning that much harder.










































































